Maybe the market is telling you that SF house prices are wildly overvalued. Maybe the best move is not to wait for ever higher prices, but sell now.
People seem to be programmed to buy high and sell low, making the old truism to do the opposite very difficult in practice. Your description isn't uncommon, but is very characteristic of the physiology of a top.
Housing price in SF are tied to valuation of tech companies. Valuation goes up, house prices go up.
I actually think houses in Bay Area are cheap.
Total profit = (Rental cashflow + appreciation) - (Maintenance + other costs)
If you predict appreciation to be high, it may offset low net cashflow or even negative net cashflow. Especially if you use leverage (loans), and have appreciation of 5%+/year.
In Austin it's similar (maybe not as extreme): a $300,000 house may rent for $1,500/mo which probably doesn't even cover the mortgage. But 5%/year is $1250/mo. AND there are more than a few tax advantages to barely making money renting (or losing) but selling at a profit later. I am not an accountant or landlord, but I have run the math and it seems to make sense.
I was reading a bit about renting as a business (plus I have 1 house in Bay Area I rent) and there is so-called rule of 1%, which means for cash flow to be positive you should rent your house for at least 1% of its market price. But it is just not the case in the SF area, you can get 0.3-0.4% at best. House with 1M price can be rented for 4K, which can’t even cover mortgage + tax, I’m not talking about repairs. Based on rule it should be 10k to make it interesting for the investors (buy and rent to make some profit). The only reason I didn’t sell it is the hope that prices will go up in x years, but right now I technically subsidizing people living there + waiting on possible rent increase in couple years. With rent control in place I would’ve been pressured to sell or live there myself. And as I moved out for an interesting opportunity, in a different market I would’ve just stayed in Bay Area. Which will not lead to drop in prices, But to decrease of available housing.
In supply/demand problem, the only way to decrease price is by increasing supply, not caping the price.
And the reason I would’ve stayed in Bay Area is cause I can’t afford to rent a place for a true market price. I’m right now paying 5k for the house which is around 1.5M (should be 15k, right?), which is mind blowing. The only reason it is possible is that the owner bought it long time ago and had the opportunity to pay it off. Buying it right now would require 300k in cash + 5.7k mortgage + 1.5k for taxes. + maintenance
So, to me, market rent control already there. And it is already on the verge of what financially feasible.