News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Authentication and the Have I Been Pwned API by mfkp on Friday July 19, 2019 @12:32PM (#20480084)
It does cost money to run a service like this. He's historically had sponsors, but you can't expect someone to run a high traffic service for free forever.
Re:Authentication and the Have I Been Pwned API by w3rhn2j34oh5o on Friday July 19, 2019 @04:31PM (#20482199)
And the local pawn shop has expenses too. Just because they have to pay rent and electricity costs does not make selling a stolen item legal.
Re:Authentication and the Have I Been Pwned API by mfkp on Friday July 19, 2019 @04:39PM (#20482267)
There's a difference - he's not selling the leaked passwords. He's selling the information that a password has been leaked for a certain account. You can't buy stolen passwords from the site, so it's perfectly legal.
Re:Authentication and the Have I Been Pwned API by w3rhn2j34oh5o on Friday July 19, 2019 @04:45PM (#20482306)
I don't think it is that clear -- he is selling access to a data set containing PII (email address or account names). Its stolen data. One can make a case that free and open access to this data set is a common good, however once money is involved, one is conducting business with data that one did not legally obtain. It is not 'perfectly legal'.
Re:Authentication and the Have I Been Pwned API by Aeolun on Saturday July 20, 2019 @04:37AM (#20484752)
I don’t think the API ever returns that information. You need to already have the email address to be queried.
Re:Authentication and the Have I Been Pwned API by penagwin on Friday July 19, 2019 @02:51PM (#20481442)
He gives a cost breakdown showing that he's almost guaranteed to lose money off it. Azure is charging him 3.5$ per 1 million calls to ratelimit/charge people for using the api. He's charging 3.5$. Consider that Stripe will be taking another 35 cents or so... lets just say if this was a monetization method it's not a very good one.
Re:Authentication and the Have I Been Pwned API by w3rhn2j34oh5o on Friday July 19, 2019 @04:30PM (#20482183)
He can try to justify it however he likes -- its selling stolen goods. Just because you sell stolen goods under their value, or under your costs to provide does not suddenly make it ok.
Re:Authentication and the Have I Been Pwned API by sho on Friday July 19, 2019 @06:46PM (#20483073)
Oh come on. It is plainly evident that he is not "selling stolen goods". He is providing a valuable public service merely checking whether people are caught up in those "stolen goods" and the context in which it occurred. In these changes, he is seeking only to recover his costs and reduce the time he spends administrating it, which he has done at absolutely no charge for 5+ years.

You are quite simply wrong and you should just admit it, rather than repeating your ludicrous claims in ever more hysterical terms.

Re:Authentication and the Have I Been Pwned API by sucrose on Friday July 19, 2019 @12:47PM (#20480264)
I don't see it as him monetizing the stolen data, but the mere existence of it.
Re:Authentication and the Have I Been Pwned API by wolco on Friday July 19, 2019 @02:45PM (#20481388)
No getting around that he sell access to stolen data.

He didn't orginally steal it. He collected the illegal dumps and runs a service on top of that data.

There is nothing wrong selling stolen data provided someone else dumped it first.

Re:Authentication and the Have I Been Pwned API by w3rhn2j34oh5o on Friday July 19, 2019 @04:28PM (#20482159)
So fencing stolen goods is not illegal if someone else stole it? I don't think so. Stolen is stolen -- nobody has any right to sell it.