Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by thrusong on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:55PM
(#20463910)
I'm actually surprised to see these negative comments... I didn't realize it grew out of favour with its audience so much.
They slowed down in season two and it had an overall pretty different tone, but they laid the groundwork for some amazing storytelling in season three where things really just fell in place together.
Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by obelos on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @05:20PM
(#20464151)
Agreed. I didn't feel like the later seasons slowed down so much as take the story darker, lingering a bit in places to draw out the contrast. And even if one finds the story lagging, the score by Mac Quayle is sufficient reason to check it out!
Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by shredprez on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @05:16PM
(#20464117)
Totally agree. It's a pulpy show (hacker noir?), but the shifting pace and focus throughout the three seasons that have aired have consistently kept me entertained.
Corny earnestness aside, I think it does a great job exploring the tension between software that eats the world and the people who live in it, between liberation and anarchy, and the "reality" of revolution in a global political context.
It's a fun show to think too much about and I'm really looking forward to this final season.
Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by RandomInteger4 on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:59PM
(#20463949)
I think a lot of it has to do with the original audience being largely composed of the "burn capitalism to the ground" types of folks, who still feel that way, whilst the series itself is showing the negative ramifications of those actions.
Folks want to live in a fantasy where they save the world that they feel so much pain in, and they can't stomach the idea that their pain is a product of their own mind rather than the world in which they reside where so many others are happily living their lives.
Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by barrkel on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @05:06PM
(#20464020)
That's not right either.
The economy, and people's place in the whole pecking order, isn't under anyone's control, really. People who are on the losing end want to change the system; sometimes their pattern-recognition sees conspiracies, or lets them believe in stories about how the system is oppressing them, but their responses don't necessarily lead to a better system.
That doesn't mean that they were wrong, that the system couldn't be better. Just that the stories that they used to make sense of the world didn't give them good tools to improve things. Most economic and social stories are like this - they become viral by being simple enough for a lot of people to understand, but fundamentally the whole system has feedback loops and second and third order effects dominate when people try to change the system.
There aren't any simple solutions, but simple solutions helped by simple stories are getting a lot of traction these days, on both left and right ends of the political spectrum.
Don't underestimate the power of self-delusion in justifying one's own position, if you think you're doing well. It's easy to start thinking that poor people deserve to be poor as a coping mechanism for the guilt you might otherwise feel.
Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by RandomInteger4 on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @05:21PM
(#20464155)
I don't mind the people who want to make the world a better place.
I mind the people who want to do so without regard for the consequences and collateral damage of their actions, which can hurt those they think they're trying to help.
I mind the radicals. They are dangerous. They don't have a sane mindset. Worse than them though are the ones like them who don't care about making the world a better place, but rather simply want to see the world burn, because they are angry. These are the people that manipulate good causes towards not so good ends.
Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by wickedOne on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @06:12PM
(#20464569)
i think that's why people lost interest; most of them who liked series 1 weren't interested in series 2, while the people who might have liked series 2 weren't interested in series 1...
flipping sides apparently didn't really pay off for mr robot.
nevertheless i think mr robot set a higher standard for hacker related productions
Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by wil421 on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:40PM
(#20463747)
The show had potential but I lost interest. The big revelation about the main character was not executed well. The writers were terrible and from the outside it looked like they just picked the hottest topics from the weekly tech news blogs.
Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by rkachowski on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:47PM
(#20463836)
I agree, they lean far too heavily on the fight club tropes - which sucks because the characters worked really well without that unnecessary twist. After the first season it seems like the tech / hacker details were just shoe-horned in after the fact.
Not to mention the awkward alexa product placement...
Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by wil421 on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:56PM
(#20463919)
The characters were great without the twist. Some shows need a twist to make the characters compelling but not here. I need to finish season 3 and I’ll still end up watching 4.
Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by pier25 on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @05:22PM
(#20464163)
> The big revelation about the main character was not executed well.
Yep. It was too obvious and we've already seen that in Fight Club.
It would have been a lot better if Elliot had never figured it out but the writers had left little breadcrumbs here and there for the internet to make conspiracy theories.
Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by RandomInteger4 on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @08:49PM
(#20465591)
"We've already seen that in XYZ" seems like a really bad argument for disliking something. That's like saying that Game of Thrones shouldn't have been made, since we've already seen a medieval / fantasy show in the form of Lord of the Rings.
Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by noir_lord on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:52PM
(#20463882)
Loved first season, gave up after two episodes of season two never went back, too many good books and tv shows to waste time on something I don’t enjoy.
Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by azhenley on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @05:06PM
(#20464012)
I chose to watch Mr. Robot over Halt and Catch Fire (I limit my time watching TV!) but I see a lot of negative comments here about Mr. Robot (and I partially agree).
Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by slx26 on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @05:28PM
(#20464225)
I really recommend Halt and Catch Fire. It grows season after season (though others clearly disagree with this opinion), and at least to me, it left a really nice feeling when I finished it, the feeling that it was worth the time and that it had been a great journey.
Mr. Robot has more impact, but after the first season, it has had many highs and lows, confusing at times, you are left asking yourself: should I continue watching? Well, very different styles. And it will surely deliver quite a few great moments more. It depends on what you are looking for.
Re:Mr. Robot Season 4 Teaser
by randallsquared on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @05:20PM
(#20464150)
It did go downhill rather quickly, though. The first season was awesome, and the second was watchable. Only momentum kept me watching to the end of the third.
They slowed down in season two and it had an overall pretty different tone, but they laid the groundwork for some amazing storytelling in season three where things really just fell in place together.
Corny earnestness aside, I think it does a great job exploring the tension between software that eats the world and the people who live in it, between liberation and anarchy, and the "reality" of revolution in a global political context.
It's a fun show to think too much about and I'm really looking forward to this final season.
Folks want to live in a fantasy where they save the world that they feel so much pain in, and they can't stomach the idea that their pain is a product of their own mind rather than the world in which they reside where so many others are happily living their lives.
The economy, and people's place in the whole pecking order, isn't under anyone's control, really. People who are on the losing end want to change the system; sometimes their pattern-recognition sees conspiracies, or lets them believe in stories about how the system is oppressing them, but their responses don't necessarily lead to a better system.
That doesn't mean that they were wrong, that the system couldn't be better. Just that the stories that they used to make sense of the world didn't give them good tools to improve things. Most economic and social stories are like this - they become viral by being simple enough for a lot of people to understand, but fundamentally the whole system has feedback loops and second and third order effects dominate when people try to change the system.
There aren't any simple solutions, but simple solutions helped by simple stories are getting a lot of traction these days, on both left and right ends of the political spectrum.
Don't underestimate the power of self-delusion in justifying one's own position, if you think you're doing well. It's easy to start thinking that poor people deserve to be poor as a coping mechanism for the guilt you might otherwise feel.
I mind the people who want to do so without regard for the consequences and collateral damage of their actions, which can hurt those they think they're trying to help.
I mind the radicals. They are dangerous. They don't have a sane mindset. Worse than them though are the ones like them who don't care about making the world a better place, but rather simply want to see the world burn, because they are angry. These are the people that manipulate good causes towards not so good ends.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Mr._Robot_episodes#Rat...
flipping sides apparently didn't really pay off for mr robot.
nevertheless i think mr robot set a higher standard for hacker related productions
Not to mention the awkward alexa product placement...
..but ofc I'll still end up watching it
Yep. It was too obvious and we've already seen that in Fight Club.
It would have been a lot better if Elliot had never figured it out but the writers had left little breadcrumbs here and there for the internet to make conspiracy theories.
And the problem is not so much that it had been done before but that it was obvious.
The second season was dull and the third I had to force myself to finish just to be a completionist. Don't think I can watch another season, sadly.
It just fell of a cliff quality wise.
So did I make the wrong choice?
Mr. Robot has more impact, but after the first season, it has had many highs and lows, confusing at times, you are left asking yourself: should I continue watching? Well, very different styles. And it will surely deliver quite a few great moments more. It depends on what you are looking for.