Re:Issue: find a new home for repos including Requests
by ijpoijpoihpiuoh on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:14PM
(#20463505)
So it seems. Would that be a problem for some reason?
Re:Issue: find a new home for repos including Requests
by Deimorz on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:25PM
(#20463600)
"Buy this and you will be able to put any code you want into any project that uses Requests and doesn't carefully audit the changes in new versions" is potentially a pretty huge problem, yes.
Similar issues have already happened with people buying or otherwise taking over popular NPM packages.
Re:Issue: find a new home for repos including Requests
by Spivak on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:29PM
(#20463639)
I mean this isn't that weird. I'm sure a lot of companies would like to buy 'control' of the project and move it in the direction that the original maintainers didn't necessarily want to. Plus being the company/org that maintains requests is pretty good PR.
There is absolutely an exchange of value here, no reason to assume that a change in maintainership means cash for malware.
Re:Issue: find a new home for repos including Requests
by ijpoijpoihpiuoh on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:40PM
(#20463748)
IMO people should have a right to sell things they've made. I get that that is inconvenient to open source folks. And most of the time it will be fine. But, IMO, if this is a concern, someone should make it worth it to this owner not to sell it to a bad organization. It is just not good enough to say, "You can't sell this thing because it is inconvenient to me, someone with whom you have no contract and to whom you owe no duties."
Re:Issue: find a new home for repos including Requests
by bhaak on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:53PM
(#20463888)
What about the other maintainers of the code?
If you are the sole person that contributed code, that's fine, but what about codebases that had lots of code contributed by other people?
Re:Issue: find a new home for repos including Requests
by LyndsySimon on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @05:37PM
(#20464315)
What’s being transferred here isn’t ownership of all the code, but control of the project and the IP associated with it.
Re:Issue: find a new home for repos including Requests
by JadeNB on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:29PM
(#20463635)
> "Buy this and you will be able to put any code you want into any project that uses Requests and doesn't carefully audit the changes in new versions" is potentially a pretty huge problem, yes.
Would not taking money somehow obviate the issue?
Re:Issue: find a new home for repos including Requests
by LyndsySimon on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:27PM
(#20463619)
This immediately follows:
> I am considering this an unlikely and rare situation. Only serious offers will be considered, and money won't influence maintainer-ship decisions.
Re:Issue: find a new home for repos including Requests
by AmrMostafa on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @08:51PM
(#20465604)
> Only serious offers will be considered, and money won't influence maintainer-ship decisions
Am I somehow misinterpreting that, or was that really a blatant attempt to sell the repos and pypi ownership of some extremely popular Python libraries?