Re:Ask HN: Is it ok to make a list of female software devs a...
by program_whiz on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @01:08PM
(#20461675)
Yes, this is a good point. Hiring "the best" is more like a multi-variable optimization problem. Pareto showed mathematically its very unlikely that there is a single "best", instead there is a population of non-dominated solutions that form the "Pareto frontier" which is a population of "less bad than other" choices. One variable in that might be gender. But again, forming a list of female engineers seems like its premature optimization on a single axis.
The best approach in these cases is as I said on another comment, take your top candidates, some are likely to be female and you can weight that dimension fittingly (e.g. we have no women, its slightly more important than having just any another C++ dev).
I find this idea to be pervasive and completely inaccurate.
The hiring process we all go through is flawed and can at best say, "this person is likely capable of doing the job as required" and sometimes they even get that wrong! There's no way to accurately rank candidates by determining Person A earned 943 Qualification Points and Person B earned 894. So you might as well take the list of people you like, and hire from that based on other qualities you want from your team.
Trying to achieve a balance of genders is important on a lot of teams. A hospital might want to hire more male nurses because certain situations might call be better handled by a male, i.e., lifting heavy patients or for patient comfort during certain procedures. Thus, if you have a list of nurses you feel are qualified, you may favor hiring male candidate if your team has a huge gender imbalance.
Our field is no different, may you'd prefer to hire a female tech lead because of an influx of female interns from the local college or because your clients/customers have a female bias and hiring that candidate may provide intangible benefits.