This could actually be pretty effective. Airbnb is very quick about disappearing anything from their platform with a less than perfect rating.

I discovered this after stumbling across some darkly funny bad reviews and then diving into their API to look for more of the same.

..Not that I am neither condoning nor condemning finding a way to dock the property a star over time. Personally I'm pretty tolerant of happy neighbourly noise - I like to feel like I have life around me, and I have a fairly good memory of how loud a neighbor I was when I was younger.