I think Medium's move is a winner and as a result, I started three profitable publications there. But... I'm worried about getting squeezed down the road. Right now Medium passes all their subscriber revenue on to the authors & publishers. But eventually they'll have to take a cut and the size of that cut will be balanced out by what other opportunities authors and publishers have.
So I think it's great that the ecosystem for paid writing is growing (Substack & Patreon). And I think paid is a great model now that we've seen what the mature version of free looks like (IMO, very bad). As an occasional writer, it's refreshing to just write the best piece I know how without trying to hack in virality and upsells.
Just at the surface level, they're probably bringing about 50% of the traffic to a new article.
Then, Medium is also a network of authors. And so those authors tend to submit articles to the most visible publications and Medium handles paying those authors.
They've really created a nice situation where people like me who are interested in the content side of publishing can run a publishing business without having to do the business side of publishing.
It might not last forever (nothing does), but they're on the upswing. We were their first external partnership and then did two publications a few months ago. I think they're about to announce deals with about 20 publications from the community. That's good since there's been a lot of noise about pubs leaving. The ones that are staying are pretty happy.
Is this something you could make a living off being an "editor" of popular publications?
So don't get too attached to this version of Substack--it's temporary. And IMO, that's totally fine. It just means you need to be ready to pivot along with them (and/or have a plan B business).
But what about integrity of service over time then?
All of this means losing initial flavor of 'doing-things-differently', a lot of other companies can provide boilerplate '-stack' for publishing newsletter (ie, recent yc news -https://github.com/knadh/listmonk - self hosted). So, in the end, the only edge of content hosting platform is how well it delivers it's content (UX, rec systems, internal ads), the bigger substack gets, the less of an edge for its creator base it will have - same as medium.com.
I risk a statement that substack is happening only because medium.com is ending.
Yes, as an author I would be interested in hassle free publishing, but after that, i am interested only in how service is helping me grow an audience, nothing else.
But setting up a newsletter isn’t without its own costs and considerations. What platform do you use, how much does it cost to send emails (something that’s hard to ascertain if you don’t know how many subscribers you have), checking formatting for various mail clients and services, avoiding being marked as a spammer, etc. And that’s before you get into the aspect of creating the newsletter — which again, TinyLetter aside, is often difficult because most newsletter services are geared towards marketing/customer acquisition, rather than something akin to a blog.
And if you want to charge for your newsletter, that’s another challenge. You have to figure out a payment processor, a membership signup system, deal with account issues, etc.
For the Ben Thompsons’s of the world who were early/pioneered the game of paid subscription newsletters, the investment costs of infrastructure and technology is probably worth it. But for many others, it’s not.
So Substack has the potential to be that defacto place/platform. I see it as trying to be the Blogger or WordPress.com for content-based newsletters, subscription or not.
I’ve almost started a newsletter about 18 times and I even signed up with Substack a few years ago (but haven’t set it up yet because I had a few concerns about how to migrate away from Substack), because of all the options — it’s the one that seems to have the least-amount of friction.
Now, in a perfect world, there would be an open-source way to do all of this with the option for both hosted and self-hosted options. Owen Williams’ newsletter/website Char.gd [1] has a great setup (he showed it to me at XOXO last year) and I know Ernie Smith from Tedium [2] has a really cool custom setup as well. I’ve been wanting to convince either or both of them to go in on a platform for this concept with me, because although I think Substack is definitely the easier way to do things for lots of users — there’s also a market (albeit smaller) for people who might want to have more control over the platform/ecosystem, but don’t want to have to cobble the whole thing together.
[1]: https://char.gd/ [2]: https://tedium.co/
Is that an acronym?
The current subscriber figure I've seen is around 50k paid subscribers across all newsletters. I think even in a best case scenario of having 1m subscribers pay $10/month, that is 1m x $10/mo x 12mo x 10% = $12m in revenue/year (at 20x the current subscriber rate). Unclear how that translates to a VC-sized unicorn biz.