"The sky is blue." "He's a Nazi!" is ad hominem.
"Has anyone noticed the Jews have an awful lot of banking jobs?" "He's a Nazi!" is, if true, very relevant. The first statement is likely not just a mere observation that may be true or may be false but is historically associated with antisemitism and is probably being used as the thin end of the wedge and not a neutral observation. It's relevant here because it expands into an argument where the origins and motivations of the arguer are in fact very relevant.
Similarly, when you see a new physics theory coming from a known crackpot, while the fact they are a crackpot may technically have no effect on the truth value of the theory, when it comes time for you to evaluate the theory you are justified in noticing it's coming from a crackpot.
Bayesian logic lets you express it even more cleanly; in Aristotelian logic the motivations of the speaker are irrelevant to the abstract truth of the statement; in more practical Bayesian logic, as you personally examine the likely truth value of somebody else's statement (with no presumption of access to the abstract truth) their motivations can be very relevant. "ad hominem" is over-weighting their motivations or falsely weighting their motivations, and under this formulation you also get reverse ad hominem, in which you under-weight their motivations, which is every much a fallacy as the original ad hominem, and which Zed talks about in his post.
All things considered, people being hyper about ad hominem is probably better than letting it slide too often, because it is certainly true that on average it is not a valid attack. But he's absolutely correct that it is sometimes valid, and while I'm not sure Zed's necessarily correct about Tor, I do think he's a lot more justified in his opinions than the pileon here consensus is indicating.
"He's a Bayesian!"
For example, your post doesn't have a single link giving counter evidence. You'd think you could bring some of that out but so far, in this entire thread, there hasn't been one link with counter evidence. There's been links to our twitter conversation, links to things supporting Tor is crap, links to discussions of Steganography, but so far I can't see 1, not ONE link with counter evidence proving me wrong.
I actually would love some, and was hoping I'd get some since I provided references, but nope. Just bullshit rhetoric and ad hominem from people who claim to hate bullshit rhetoric and ad hominem. So don't go acting like you're all above the drama.
Zed, find a therapist, please. You are a talented person but your mind needs debugging.
And, Thomas, "ritualizing" may be the only way to keep forensics sound. When you prove something, you want it to remain proved.
Note that those two things can be conflated in one: if you disapprove some goal, then a part of your goal is to make that not happen. So in the end, the only thing that matters is the influence of the deed on your goals, period.
Now the deed cannot be evaluated alone. You need to know how it interacts with the world. And the first place to look at is the other deeds of the same person. (There lies the validity of Ad Hominem arguments.) However it's not the only place to look at.
For instance, if a Paper-Clip-Maniac wants to solve the Friendly AI problem, you probably don't want that problem solved: it could fill the universe with paper clips, wiping out all sentient life in the process. Now, say you're a transhumanist, and you want to cure Death. Solving the FAI problem suddenly look much better. It may even be worth the risk induced by that Paper-Clip-Maniac.
This is probably why Zed has the words "Conflict Of Interest" as a section heading in a very large font.
For example: "I will go on record right now saying Wikileaks rocks. ... if anyone from Wikileaks tries to work with me or on any project I'm on you bet your ass I'm not trusting them one bit. Never trust a traitor, no matter how noble their intentions."
So Wikileaks "rocks", yet anyone involved in Wikileaks is a traitor and shouldn't be trusted? That seems contradictory. Taking this logic further, are journalists who cite Wikileaks' work also traitors that shouldn't be trusted?
As a fan of Zed's and someone that isn't completely sold on Tor, I'd love to see a sober critique of the project's vulnerbilities from Zed, but this post isn't it.
a) Read Greenwald Salon article accusing Wired of having shady connections.
b) Roll that basic premise into a set of wild accusations and things we already know about Tor.
c) Sit back and enjoy the whole chaos of the troll. When someone attacks bring out the usual sockpuppets and sycophants to say "but Zed does all this great coding", "Zed is not like that in real life/conferences".
d) Profit/save on therapist fees by feeding own teenager-like angst and need for attention.