News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pop culture loves the 'butterfly effect' and gets it wrong by roel_v on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @03:31AM (#20448171)
What caught my eye in this article was this sentence:

"This is a founding idea of chaos theory, whose advocates sometimes say Lorenz helped dispel the Newtonian idea of a wholly predictable universe."

Maybe someone more well-versed in physics than myself can comment: is it really so that 'metaphysical determinism' (so to say) is specific to Newtonian physics, and so, that it's no longer the state of the art in our understanding of nature? In other words, is there no room for Laplace's demon beyond classical mechanics? That would take the concept of the nature of 'randomness' beyond what I so far understood it to be.

Re:Pop culture loves the 'butterfly effect' and gets it wrong by rwallace on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @03:44AM (#20448229)
Metaphysical determinism still works in relativity. It also still works in quantum mechanics if you accept the many-worlds interpretation.

That's quite orthogonal to the question of practical predictability. What chaos theory shows is that, regardless of which model of microscopic physics we are talking about, there are important aspects of the future that cannot be predicted to high precision from within the universe.

Re:Pop culture loves the 'butterfly effect' and gets it wrong by jhrmnn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @04:56AM (#20448501)
No, it doesn't work in quantum mechanics. Even under many-worlds, the result of a measurement is fundamentally indeterminable until it is realized. In many-worlds parlance—which "world" you end up in is indeterminable.
Re:Pop culture loves the 'butterfly effect' and gets it wrong by adrianN on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @07:31AM (#20449098)
You end up in all the worlds.
Re:Pop culture loves the 'butterfly effect' and gets it wrong by jmaa on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @03:51AM (#20448256)
The word "predictable" implies "deterministic", but they are not identical. The universe can be governed by strong deterministic laws, while being too complex to simulate and thus predict.

This poses some difficult questions for science, given that most science up to now has been about predicting something, trying it and checking whether theory and practice matches.

Re:Pop culture loves the 'butterfly effect' and gets it wrong by roel_v on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @05:55AM (#20448719)
Right, but I took the comment in the OP to mean that non-Newtonian physics makes things 'non-deterministic', even is we leave aside the practicality of simulating the universe at the molecular (or smaller?) level.