News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pop culture loves the 'butterfly effect' and gets it wrong by Retric on Monday July 15, 2019 @09:11PM (#20446715)
The weather patterns, infrastructure, and economic constants are going to be nearly identical. Roll back the clock 2,000 years and you would still see major cities mostly at the same rivers and ports.

Major inventions often have several people making the same basic discovery at the same time. You can’t build heavier than air controlled flight without efficient engines. You can’t build efficient engines without high precision manufacturing. Which requires it’s own constraints etc.

Replay the last 30 years and Dell might not have been the mail/phone then internet order PC vender to become a household name. But, one of them would because several where trying and efficiency of scale is a major advantage.

PS: One if my favorite examples is in a high school science class I was messing around with a power supply and mechanical pencil lead. It ended up making a rather bright light, in a moment of wonder I realized I had become possibly the millionth person to discover a precursor light bulb. Well over a hundred years late by on measure but in terms of the 100,000’s of years history of humanity fairly close.

Re:Pop culture loves the 'butterfly effect' and gets it wrong by skybrian on Monday July 15, 2019 @10:01PM (#20446919)
On the other hand, going to war (or not) could either accelerate or prevent major technological progress. And that depends on politics. So it seems like that's not all that predictable either?
Re:Pop culture loves the 'butterfly effect' and gets it wrong by anyfoo on Monday July 15, 2019 @09:39PM (#20446832)
I agree that there would probably still be major cities at the same rivers, but they would not be speaking any language you would recognize.

Also, it's not that hard to discover electric light if you have a fully working power supply already... just about any piece of conductive material that is too small to handle the current going through it will make some light of varying intensity, so that realization probably came very very quickly after the concept of electricity was born. (The hard part was then to make that light last.)

Re:Pop culture loves the 'butterfly effect' and gets it wrong by Retric on Monday July 15, 2019 @10:01PM (#20446913)
Different language but a similar diet at the list of domesticated plants and animals has not changed all that rapidly. Which means at least some aspects of culture would be similar.

As to light requiring a power supply that’s my point. Roll back 50 years to 1969 and they had integrated circuits, phones, radios, batteries, CCD, and networked computers. Without WWIII the odds seem high they would end up with highly capable cellphones with cameras, internet access, and reasonably familiar form factors due to human hands.

GPS being a free public system links to a specific aircraft being shot down. So that’s questionable, but we had early satellite navigation. Thus, the odds are good the military at least would have a similar system and if nothing else a paid for version via private companies seems likely.

Chaos theory uses the term strange attractors to these kinds of situations. Minor changes are generally going to end up in very similar situations.