News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Haskell and the "foul stench of cargo cult mathematics" by Zaak on Monday December 27, 2010 @08:46PM (#2044295)
> Basically, the author seems upset that "5" is a Number rather than an Integer. But that's fine, because it's true. 5 is a real fraction. 5 is a complex fraction. 5 is a double. 5 is a char. 5 is an unsigned long long. 5 is a lot of things to a computer. So sometimes, you have to tell it which one you want.

A contributing factor here is that there are no subtype relations in Haskell. In math, "5" is all of those things simultaneously, but in Haskell it can only be one at a time.

Re:Haskell and the "foul stench of cargo cult mathematics" by thesz on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @07:39AM (#2045313)
>In math, "5" is all of those things simultaneously, but in Haskell it can only be one at a time.

How is that?

Excerpts from ghci dialog:

  Prelude> :t 5
  5 :: (Num t) => t
  class (Num a) => Fractional a where
    (/) :: a -> a -> a
    recip :: a -> a
    fromRational :: Rational -> a
  Prelude Data.Complex> :i RealFrac
  class (Real a, Fractional a) => RealFrac a where
  ...
  Prelude Data.Complex> :i RealFloat
  class (RealFrac a, Floating a) => RealFloat a where
  ...
  Prelude Data.Complex> :i Complex
  data (RealFloat a) => Complex a = !a :+ !a
  instance (RealFloat a) => Eq (Complex a)
So, 5 is an Int, Integer, Rational, Double and Complex (which, actually, could be Complex Int or Complex Double).
Re:Haskell and the "foul stench of cargo cult mathematics" by Zaak on Thursday December 30, 2010 @03:48PM (#2053562)
(Num t) => t means that the value can have the type of any member of class Num, but it can't be more than one type at a time. There are no subtypes in Haskell.