News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MIT AI tool can predict breast cancer up to 5 years early by magwa101 on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:06PM (#20442842)
Cost of false positive is retest and observe, this seems like a very low cost. Also, stop consuming sugar.
Re:MIT AI tool can predict breast cancer up to 5 years early by SolaceQuantum on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:37PM (#20443202)
Sorry, please explain to me if my interpretation is correct:

1. The cost of a false positive is low. 1a. The cost of a false positive is retesting (what is retesting? Re-mammogramming? Isn't healthcare in USA expensive?) 1b. Observe (so future re-mammogramming and hypervigilance).

2. Additional to the cost of 1a and 1b, cease consuming sugar. Which is a non-insignificant lifestyle change.

What I'm saying is... the statements "Rerun expensive tests and maintain hypervigilance seems like a low cost, in addition to major lifestyle changes that affect every level of one's socioeconomic place (eating out with friends/family, cost of food, food availability, habit breaking, possibly culture clashes, etc)." seems pretty much equivalent to absolute nonsense.

Re:MIT AI tool can predict breast cancer up to 5 years early by timthorn on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:19PM (#20442978)
What about the anxiety and distress caused to the patient? How many might undergo an unnecessary mastectomy to be on the safe side?
Re:MIT AI tool can predict breast cancer up to 5 years early by colechristensen on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:39PM (#20443223)
I have a problem with this vision.

You can be told the risk factors for everybody, but when you are told the risk factors tailored to you it becomes dangerous? Should we tell everyone they're going to live forever so they live in ignorant bliss while healthy?

I can see being unprepared for having that information, but I don't think the solution is not having the information.

Re:MIT AI tool can predict breast cancer up to 5 years early by timthorn on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:55PM (#20443377)
It's not a risk factor; it's a test outcome. You would be told that you've tested positive with the follow on tests and anxiety that causes.

There have been studies into exactly this: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22859786

Specifically on breast cancer screening, the National Institute for Clinical Evidence in the UK has published management guidance that is quite interesting: https://cks.nice.org.uk/breast-screening

Re:MIT AI tool can predict breast cancer up to 5 years early by wccrawford on Monday July 15, 2019 @02:32PM (#20443713)
Can't read that last link outside the UK.

They wouldn't be wold they were positive for cancer. They'd be told that the computer predicts that they are at very high risk for breast cancer. That's knowledge that I think people should have, personally.

Re:MIT AI tool can predict breast cancer up to 5 years early by b_tterc_p on Monday July 15, 2019 @04:00PM (#20444597)
Given a positive result. P of having the disease are 2%. Given a false result, it’s about 0. Given 2 positive results, assuming independent results (I think that’s unlikely but let’s assume) then the probability of having it is 0.04.

I’m not disagreeing that there usefulness to tests, but there is danger too.

Re:MIT AI tool can predict breast cancer up to 5 years early by ska on Monday July 15, 2019 @06:53PM (#20446059)
If by whatever mechanism your FPR significantly increases biopsy rate, it's not a low cost.