News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Polanyi’s Paradox by lisper on Monday July 15, 2019 @11:31AM (#20441765)
I don't understand why this is a paradox. Isn't it just obvious that no system can contain a complete model of itself? That would be an infinite regress and hence would require infinite information.
Re:Polanyi’s Paradox by tlb on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:13PM (#20442923)
What does it mean for a system to contain a complete model of itself?

If I can fit all the firmware, schematics and silicon mask layouts of a laptop on that laptop's disk, in what sense does it not contain a complete model?

Concretely, consider that the CAD files describing a terabyte of flash are less than a terabyte, because most parts are repeated in a grid. And you can add more terabytes without increasing the size of the model noticeably. So the storage capacity of a system isn't limited to the descriptive complexity of the system. It's probably O(log N) with a huge constant. So you can have as much disk space as you like to store a model.

Re:Polanyi’s Paradox by joyeuse6701 on Monday July 15, 2019 @02:03PM (#20443453)
My understanding: You are containing the 'plan' or instructions to recreate or describe the system, but not the system itself. The system contains more information than what the plan can actually describe, even if you are storing duplicates in such a way as to 'reduce' it. Your plan won't be able to store, for example, the information conveyed to the nerves by touching the laptop, you may have a description, but it will only ever be a description.
Re:Polanyi’s Paradox by a1369209993 on Monday July 15, 2019 @02:36PM (#20443742)
> You are containing [...] not the system itself.

Well, sure; we're asking for a model, not a copy.

Re:Polanyi’s Paradox by natosaichek on Monday July 15, 2019 @11:48AM (#20441928)
A human contains code that can recreate a complete model of that human....

Maybe you're saying that a human can't fit into a human? I agree it's not a paradox, but not for the reasons you seem to be implying.

Re:Polanyi’s Paradox by lisper on Monday July 15, 2019 @12:02PM (#20442065)
> A human contains code that can recreate a complete model of that human

That's true, but irrelevant. We're talking about modeling a system here, not reproducing one. Those are not the same thing.

Re:Polanyi’s Paradox by SilasX on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:25PM (#20443065)
Sufficiently advanced modeling is indistinguishable from reproduction.
Re:Polanyi’s Paradox by joyeuse6701 on Monday July 15, 2019 @02:04PM (#20443461)
Wouldn't that be more like, infinitely advanced modeling is indistinguishable from reproduction?
Re:Polanyi’s Paradox by cuspycode on Monday July 15, 2019 @02:12PM (#20443531)
DNA does not encode a complete model of the human that has the DNA, it encodes a bunch of potential clones of that human. This is an abstract, incomplete model. To encode a complete model you would need a complete physical measurement of this particular human as a physical system. But there is a theorem by Thomas Breuer that no physical system can contain a complete measurement of its own state.
Re:Polanyi’s Paradox by naringas on Monday July 15, 2019 @11:57AM (#20442010)
what code are you refering to?

if you mean DNA, then humans do not "speak" (nor think in) this code, heck... teams of people with post-docs don't even really understand it.

Re:Polanyi’s Paradox by JoeAltmaier on Monday July 15, 2019 @12:05PM (#20442095)
Further, most of the 'program' is in the cellular mechanics. DNA does nothing just sitting on a table. It must have a machine to 'execute on', and the cellular machinery is a whopper.

I liken DNA to a paper tape with two punches: one for 'man' and one for 'mouse'. You run it through an enormous machine, and depending on which hole is punched you get a man or a mouse. But the paper tape is an almost trivial part of the process.

Re:Polanyi’s Paradox by komali2 on Monday July 15, 2019 @12:35PM (#20442447)
Humans don't need to self-contain an entire model of a human in their brain. Multiple humans can come together and write disparate information down, for example.
Re:Polanyi’s Paradox by ken on Monday July 15, 2019 @12:56PM (#20442703)
Humans are also pretty lousy at predicting how other human brains will react, though. I don't see how that's an example of the Paradox. With a woefully incomplete model, obviously you'll get inaccurate predictions.