There are two logical mistakes in this reasoning: first, there's an implicit equation "prohibited guns"="no guns", and it's obviously not true, and explicit statement that less guns - less murders, and even less suicides, which is provably false. Right now, I live in a country where having just a knife in your pocket can land you in prison easily. Somehow, both murder, and suicide rates are still slightly above region's average. If you don't like my anonymous witnessing, you can arrange world countries by gun prohibition/severe restriction, then look at murder, and suicide rates - you'll find no correlation. Simple as that. And before tribal instinct pushes someone to downvote this, take into account: I'm not even a US citizen/resident, and have no stakes in your politics.
However gun ownership rates: USA #1, Finland #10, Switzerland #19 [2].
For me it just shows that there is no correlation between gun ownership rates and suicide rates.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_r...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estimated_number_of_civilian_g...
I was also not talking about rates of suicide or murder, but rather success rates based on the tool/method used.
This interpretation doesn't lead us anywhere too. The most popular method to commit suicide world-wide (hanging) has near 100% effectiveness.
well http://lostallhope.com/suicide-methods/statistics-most-letha...
documented https://jech.bmj.com/content/57/2/120
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18245314
I'm not sure why you get to declare a lie as a fact without evidence, and I'm the one who has to provide links to call that out?
[1] Source: I was trained when volunteered in suicide prevention program.
Lucky you're not in WA where a 10/22 IS an "assault rifle"
It's interesting how this falls in to the typically conservative "legislate the vice away" approach to social ills. Conservatives often want to take something that is causing harm to some people, and ban everyone from having it (drugs, alcohol prohibition, free love), under the argument that the light enjoyment of the many is not worth a few people having their lives ruined through lack of self-control. However because by a pure accident of history it's the rural voting block that is conservative and likes guns, it's typically-liberal people who want to legislate the vice away, arguing that the fun that a subculture is having is not worth the suicide deaths.
I think this is because people only apply the utility calculation to other people, but treat themselves like they have free will. Everyone thinks that they should be treated as if they can be responsible, but nobody wants to treat other people like they can be responsible.