News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook’s $5B FTC fine is an embarrassing joke by tptacek on Saturday July 13, 2019 @09:49AM (#20428044)
No, it's not:

* The fine, an FTC record-breaker, is equivalent to the cost of simultaneous acquisitions of multiple high-profile startups.

* A mid-single-digits repetition of this fine would deplete Facebook's cash reserves entirely.

* The fine covers specific conduct committed by Facebook (violations of their previous consent decree) that almost certainly netted the company multiple orders of magnitude less money than the fine cost them.

* The fine was anticipated long before it was announced and has been priced into Facebook's stock; we can't look at the spot price now and know what it would have been without the fine factored in, because that's not how stock prices work.

The purpose of the fine wasn't to punish Facebook for being Facebook; much as I might want that to happen, FTC doesn't have the authority to do that, nor should it, since it's an unelected administrative apparatus without lawmaking power. The point is to deter future violations of this and similar consent decrees at Facebook and other companies (Facebook being the largest of that cohort of companies). It surely accomplished that: whatever money Facebook made off of Cambridge Analytica and similar enterprises is surely dwarfed by the $5B fine, since chicanery like that isn't Facebook's core business.

In the US, when a wealthy person parks in front of a fire hydrant, we don't give them a $100,000 parking ticket; the fine is scaled to the offense, not the offender.

Re:Facebook’s $5B FTC fine is an embarrassing joke by beefield on Saturday July 13, 2019 @10:53AM (#20428325)
> In the US, when a wealthy person parks in front of a fire hydrant, we don't give them a $100,000 parking ticket; the fine is scaled to the offense, not the offender.

Really?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebeck_v._McDonald%27s_Restau...

My personal opinion is that that is the pointa that is probably most broken in the US legal system.

Fines should be penalties for breaking the law. And they should hurt, which means that fines for wealthy persons should be bigger than for less wealthy people, otherwise wealthy people can break law with no practical repercussions. And fines should be paid to the government, not to the victim.

On the other side of the coin, the payments due to damage caused due to illegal activities should just cover the damages and no more to the party that has been the victim of the damage. It is completely ridiculous that you can expect to get wealthy if you can convince a jury that the coffee you bought was too hot.

Re:Facebook’s $5B FTC fine is an embarrassing joke by sethev on Saturday July 13, 2019 @01:22PM (#20429079)
You should read the article you linked. "Liebeck suffered permanent disfigurement after the incident and was partially disabled for two years." The fact that people remember "crazy lady didn't know coffee was hot" is due to corporate PR. It worked on the public but not on the jury who heard the facts directly.
Re:Facebook’s $5B FTC fine is an embarrassing joke by TazeTSchnitzel on Saturday July 13, 2019 @10:58AM (#20428338)
> In the US, when a wealthy person parks in front of a fire hydrant, we don't give them a $100,000 parking ticket; the fine is scaled to the offense, not the offender.

Yes, but the US's system of fines might be considered regressive (big enough to hurt poor people, small enough to mean nothing to rich people) compared to countries which use day fines which are in fact scaled to the offender.

Re:Facebook’s $5B FTC fine is an embarrassing joke by panarky on Saturday July 13, 2019 @10:42AM (#20428268)
> scaled to the offense, not the offender

So how big is the offense? 80 million people directly just in the Cambridge Analytica case, plus how many hundreds of millions indirectly through the resulting election hijinks?

Facebook was already sanctioned under the consent decree, and they deliberately and recklessly disclosed user data, and then tried to cover it up.

Scaling to the offense, I'd say that a fine of far less than $100 per user is extremely lenient under these circumstances.

And just wait -- months or years from now we'll learn that Facebook didn't even pay the full $5B, but had a large portion deferred or possibly even structured with bogus "in-kind" payments.

Re:Facebook’s $5B FTC fine is an embarrassing joke by kevingadd on Saturday July 13, 2019 @09:59AM (#20428079)
"Scaled to the offense, not the offender" is a good principle, but how do you make it work for offenders like Facebook or Uber? Uber used their massive war chest to basically ignore laws on a massive scale, and we've now seen that Facebook was happy to go on and commit more violations even after being scolded by the FTC before.

What makes this fine different, other than being bigger? They can afford it. Why will they change their behavior now when they didn't before? Other companies of this sort haven't changed their behavior. Will Facebook finally learn after they commit even larger offenses and then get slapped with another larger fine 5 years later?

Like, realistically speaking: "Profit" here is not the goal, especially not in the earlier phase. FB making a billion dollars is a side effect of the other things they really want, which is growing a market and building lock-in - because those things are worth a LOT. It's the same reason Uber is willing to lose money on rides and eat legal penalties and get dragged into court: The costs are worth the result. So I'm not convinced slapping FB with a $5b fine after this long is really going to have a deterrent effect. Hopefully it does...

Re:Facebook’s $5B FTC fine is an embarrassing joke by rejschaap on Saturday July 13, 2019 @10:31AM (#20428223)
> "Scaled to the offense, not the offender" is a good principle

No, it's not, but it kinda works, well enough for most people. It punishes poor people too harshly and wealthy people can shrug it off too easily. But for the vast majority of people it works.

For companies it doesn't make sense at all, there just is too much variance between companies. I also doubt it is what happened here, the 5 billion looks scaled to the offender as well as the offense.

Re:Facebook’s $5B FTC fine is an embarrassing joke by tptacek on Saturday July 13, 2019 @10:38AM (#20428252)
In the sense that $5B almost certainly dwarfs by orders of magnitude any revenue Facebook would have earned from lax API controls and sales of data to analytics and adtech companies (gross as those practices were, they are not Facebook's core business) and thus is wildly out of proportion to the offense and thus unfairly high, yes, I agree.
Re:Facebook’s $5B FTC fine is an embarrassing joke by panarky on Saturday July 13, 2019 @03:30PM (#20429718)
The magnitude of the offence isn't measured by how much profit Facebook made from it.

When a guy robs $1000 from a bank, he'll spend years in prison.

It's a much bigger offence than the loss of $1000.

Likewise, Facebook's offence in intentionally and recklessly disclosing private data on tens of millions of users has no relationship to how much money Facebook made from the disclosure.

Re:Facebook’s $5B FTC fine is an embarrassing joke by close04 on Saturday July 13, 2019 @10:21AM (#20428174)
> "Scaled to the offense, not the offender" is a good principle, but how do you make it work for offenders like Facebook or Uber?

The problem is many people are very slow to adapt and understand that at this point enough "entities" are so rich and powerful that any scaling to the offense is practically impossible unless you want to scale the offense itself. It's the same when some people imagine everything "cyber" is perfectly analogous to the traditional ways. This also results in things that don't fit their purpose.

So either you consider Facebook's offense as far more egregious based on their size and reach and apply a proportional punishment, or you consider the offense as the same as anyone else's but you scale up the punishment.

Anything else is basically giving a get out of jail free card to the already powerful while helping eliminate their competition that can't take the same level of punishment. So without defining fines as percentage of revenue or directly punishing executives (much harder to pull off) these fines are indeed jokes. They do not achieve their purpose.

Re:Facebook’s $5B FTC fine is an embarrassing joke by nashashmi on Saturday July 13, 2019 @03:33PM (#20429736)
> fine... equivalent to... many acquisitions.

It is an apples to oranges comparison. Acquisitions aren't easy and still cost a good amount of time for implementation. Paying a fine is easy.

> repetion... would deplete... the cash reserves.

This was deducted from their quarterly profits in their quarterly report. Not reserves.

> netted the company multiple orders of magnitude less money than the fine cost them.

Again apples to oranges comparison. Act has to be compared to the larger set of actions that netted profits. If a company runs 10 initiatives and gets fined for one, it should be compared to the returns on 10 initiatives.

I want to scream this was a settlement. Not a fine. Facebook said we will pay 5B. FTC said fine. In other words, a bribe against the American people.

Cambridge analytica is a result of Facebook behavior and not a result of decision making. Fb wanted advertisers to LEARN to use its platform before they had any idea on how to do that. And Many failed in the beginning. Had Fb not been more open with their product offerings, companies would never figure out how to utilize Fb. This was both reckless and necessary. This was calculated.

Today profits dwarf the fine.

Re:Facebook’s $5B FTC fine is an embarrassing joke by 11oitap on Saturday July 13, 2019 @10:24AM (#20428192)
>>The point is to deter future violations

>>has been priced into Facebook's stock

So, the fine has failed its purpose already - considering FB stock price has now gone up when compared to when the scandals became public (choose any point on the timeline that you wish).

Anyone who thinks FB is going to change their behavior after this fine (I hope that's not what you are implying) is - how to put it nicely - not a very bright person.

Re:Facebook’s $5B FTC fine is an embarrassing joke by tptacek on Saturday July 13, 2019 @10:28AM (#20428214)
On the contrary, I think FTC's willingness to fine companies $5B --- a sum squarely in line with what investment banks were fined during the 2007-2008 crash --- will absolutely influence Facebook's behavior in the future.

People conceptualize Facebook as a single entity pursuing a single goal, and that's understandable given the company's management structure. Nonetheless, it is not that; it is a collection of organizations and product teams with differing incentive structures. The consent decree targeted specific operations in Facebook, not the company as a whole --- and those operations were idiosyncratic and outside the main flow of revenue to the company, to begin with. A business unit that makes $50MM and nets -$4.95B is one not long for this world.

And, once again, you can't know how the market priced the fine, because it was priced in long ago, and you don't have a counterfactual price-without-fine to compare it to.

Re:Facebook’s $5B FTC fine is an embarrassing joke by panarky on Saturday July 13, 2019 @10:58AM (#20428335)
The bank penalties for fraud and money laundering might be instructive here.

The headline penalty amounts were inflated with bogus dollars that the banks never actually paid.

A great example was Bank of America's purported $17 billion settlement.

https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/bank-america-pay-1665-billion...

This was really $7 billion in actual cash, plus double-counting $3 billion of pre-existing penalties that BofA hadn't paid yet, and then juiced further with totally bogus $7 billion in "homeowner relief".

That "homeowner relief" consisted of adding up "principal reductions" on bad debt that the bank had already suffered because they made bad loans, plus "new loans to credit worthy borrowers".

Like when there's a class action lawsuit for criminal corporate behavior and the "settlement" is a coupon for 20% off more purchases from the company.

The details aren't out on the Facebook settlement, but if the bank penalties are any guide, the cash actually paid could be a fraction of the $5 billion headline number.

Re:Facebook’s $5B FTC fine is an embarrassing joke by mayankkaizen on Saturday July 13, 2019 @11:47AM (#20428600)
Few years back, 5B $ fine was kinda unthinkable. Sure, FB is a big elephant but this fine is by no means a small fine. Who knows future fines might be even bigger. After all, repeated offences are generally punished harshly.

Assuming FB actually has to cough up this fine and also assuming FB won't mend its ways (logical assumption ;) ), it would definitely affect the FB in serious manner.

But yeah, I am pessimistic that FB won't mend its ways and won't pay any fine either. The will power to do that is just not there.