Tivoization is an offensive term that implies Tivo did something wrong.
TiVo is taking software that was intended to be and remain free and betraying the spirit of its license by preventing end-users from changing the devices they own.
While I won't say it's wrong or unjustifiable, I prefer more open and friendly devices and, so, I don't - and probably won't - own a TiVo, as I don't want to enable such conduct.
TiVo is taking software that was intended to be
and remain free and betraying the spirit
of its license
Linus Tolvards himself said he has no problem with Tivo, so I don't know what the fuck you're talking about, but just because somebody chose an open-source license doesn't mean it adheres to any political agenda you happen to agree with.
Re:2011: The Year Android Explodes
by burgerbrain on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:16PM
(#2043142)
The term implies no moral judgment, it simply is used to describe the technical process/effect.
The term can be used by detractors in a negative fashion, and the term can be used in a positive way by people who might be interested in doing it themselves. It's a word, it has not political opinions.
It is telling that you assume it has inherent negative connotations though.
Richard Stallman coined the term and I quote from http://www.gnu.org/licenses/rms-why-gplv3.html
One major danger that GPLv3 will block
is tivoization ... The manufacturers of
these computers take advantage of the freedom
that free software provides, but they don't
let you do likewise.
If this doesn't have a negative connotation, that I don't know what does.
Re:2011: The Year Android Explodes
by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @06:21AM
(#2045192)
Tivoization means "to do what Tivo did".
Some people disagree with what Tivo did, that doesn't make the word itself "offensive", nor does it imply wrongdoing, nor is it really a connotation, more a denotation.
If they'd went with "digital slavery" or "software piracy" then I could see where you were coming from.
Because your current preferred solution to carrier abuses, which appears to be that everyone should buy iPhones, is insane. It's Sarah Palin "Death Panel" level craziness, which is apparently only obvious to those of us outside the U.S.
Also, your irony is at least a decade late, you should read up on Tivoization (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tivoization) which qualifies as mass-market linux without final user control, but the debate about people using open code for purposes you don't like (e.g. guiding missiles, mass-surveillance) goes back much further.