News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by tmh79 on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:21PM (#20423044)
I am for the "housing first" approach, but there is a clear moral hazard when you provide free housing to the lowest rung, and then say that the minimum cost of housing for the next group is like 1.5k/bedroom/month.
Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by hguant on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:33PM (#20423148)
It's important to note that "moral hazard", while not quite a term of art, has a specific meaning in economics that isn't associated with ethics or morality.

The quick google definitions: "a lack of incentive to guard against risk where one is protected from its consequences"

Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_hazard

Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by nostrademons on Friday July 12, 2019 @05:39PM (#20424764)
He's using it correctly here though: the risk is that if you provide housing to the lowest rung while making the next group down pay $1.5K/bedroom/month, some of the next group down will decide that they would rather become part of the "lowest rung" group rather than pay the money. It's like the phenomena of people committing petty crimes so that they can get a warm bed and food in jail.
Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by dclowd9901 on Saturday July 13, 2019 @02:24AM (#20426792)
You mean like all those millionaires who decide to become thousandaires so they don't pay more taxes? Give me a break.
Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by esyir on Saturday July 13, 2019 @06:20AM (#20427382)
First, that is a terrible analogy.

If I'm interpreting the ops statement correctly, this is more analogous to a system where post-tax income decreases with rising income instead.

Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by Latteland on Friday July 12, 2019 @06:31PM (#20425117)
Your example illustrates to me why moral hazard isn't the best title for this. We should provide free housing to people in need so they don't do things like commit a crime to go to jail.
Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by robocat on Saturday July 13, 2019 @02:36AM (#20426829)
The moral hazard is for those renting: the free housing is equivalent to an insurance payout.

A renter can do risky things (like lose their job) because they are protected from the consequences of not being able to pay the rent. They get housed anyway.

Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by rebuilder on Saturday July 13, 2019 @04:29AM (#20427109)
Being able to take risks can be seen as a good thing, too. It may help class mobility.
Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by jbob2000 on Friday July 12, 2019 @05:06PM (#20424512)
This is what’s keeping me living at home with my parents. I tried to move out a few years ago, found an apartment that was $1,100 a month and plenty of parking.

6 months after moving in, after having multiple bad experiences with tenants, I realized I moved in to a “subsidized housing” apartment. There was lots of parking available because 90% of the tenants weren’t allowed to drive.

It hurts to work all day to pay for stuff, only to come home to half your neighbors lazing about drunk and stoned getting a free ride. It fucking sucks, I could never escape the thought that I could just quit my job and smoke weed all day and live pretty much the same as I was.

If I wanted to live in a condo, which doesn’t have subsidized housing, I’d have to pay rents upwards of $2,200. So I moved back in with my folks until I can buy something.

Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by CryptoPunk on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:46AM (#20426550)
>>It hurts to work all day to pay for stuff, only to come home to half your neighbors lazing about drunk and stoned getting a free ride. It fucking sucks, I could never escape the thought that I could just quit my job and smoke weed all day and live pretty much the same as I was.

I know people who work back breaking low-income jobs and get very angry seeing people on government assistance sitting around all day getting high with their friends.

I think the position of the homeless activists: of giving people with no life skills and no discipline, and who habitually abuse drugs, no-strings-attached taxpayer aid, is totally immoral and irresponsible. It's the worse example of short-sighted unthinking compassion and/or virtue-signalling.

At the very least, drug addicts who've lost the ability to support themselves should be committed to a drug rehab center. In the past the lost souls were also enrolled in work houses. Those on public aid doing some work should be another minimum requirement for any welfare system. The nature of the work can be targeted to their intellectual and physical capabilities, but they should be required to do some kind of work if they're going to receive public support.

Anyway, demanding accountability from welfare recipients is not going to win you any elections - people would rather elect someone with compassion and a terrible plan for governance than elect someone with a logically coherent governance plan who might not have compassion - so the problem will just get worse.

Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by sjs382 on Sunday July 14, 2019 @03:13PM (#20435302)
> At the very least, drug addicts who've lost the ability to support themselves should be committed to a drug rehab center.

Absent a desire to quit, rehab can't work. At that point, it's just a private prison with wallpaper.

Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by CryptoPunk on Monday July 15, 2019 @12:32AM (#20438136)
The desire to quit can be shaped by the incentives society creates. If using drugs and partying with fellow drug-using friends means continually being committed to three month stints in rehab, it might encourage that party to get out of that lifestyle.

Also, some people may decide to quit once they've been forced to stop doing drugs for a few months, because it results in lessened chemical dependency, and some time for the parts of their brain damaged from the drug-use to recover, which helps increase self-control.

We forcibly prevent children from engaging in self-destructive behaviour, because sometimes they need someone who knows better to control them, until they mature and do know better. Just because someone turns 18, doesn't always mean this stops applying. In the case of someone habitually using hard drugs, I think a strong argument can be made that it still applies because they lack the maturity and self-control to make these decisions for themselves.

Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by neonate on Friday July 12, 2019 @05:14PM (#20424578)
Good luck. Hope you get there soon.
Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by didibus on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:03AM (#20426429)
Why didn't you?
Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by vkou on Friday July 12, 2019 @06:51PM (#20425242)
> It hurts to work all day to pay for stuff, only to come home to half your neighbors lazing about drunk and stoned getting a free ride.

I hear this all the time - yet I don't see many people particularly keen on dropping out, and getting onto the free ride bus.

One of the problems with that free ride bus is that it doesn't go to great places. It didn't sound like you were looking forward to the prospect of living in subsidized housing for the rest of your life very much.

Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by freyr on Friday July 12, 2019 @11:53PM (#20426398)
> yet I don't see many people particularly keen on dropping out

Just open your eyes. Look around Seattle, or San Francisco, or Los Angeles, or San Diego or any other city with mild weather, lenient law enforcement, and generous welfare benefits. The number of homeless and housed "drop outs" is astonishing.

Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by vkou on Saturday July 13, 2019 @03:35PM (#20429747)
If you think 'dropping out' and living a homeless life is in any way preferable to the alternatives, I'd recommend spending a few days panhandling, and a few nights in a homeless shelter.

I have a feeling that you'll change your tune pretty quick after that. You'll quickly realize how dehumanizing it is to be in that position.

Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by lonelappde on Saturday July 13, 2019 @01:42PM (#20429193)
It's not. It only looks like a large number because they are all crammed into a small public space and not hidden inside condos and houses.

We have more of an epidemic of rich people squatting in hundreds of miles of waterfront property and ruining shoreline access for the public.

Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by freyr on Saturday July 13, 2019 @03:01PM (#20429582)
Wrong.

Alameda County, 43% increase in homeless population in two years.

San Francisco, 17% increase.

Orange County, 42% increase.

Kern County, 50% increase.

In Seattle/King County, 28% increase in the chronically homeless population from 2017 to 2018.

Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by michaelt on Friday July 12, 2019 @08:59PM (#20425844)

  I don't see many people particularly
  keen on dropping out, and getting
  onto the free ride bus.
I don't either - but maybe those people just don't hang out on Hacker News.
Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by topmonk on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:36AM (#20426529)
> I don't see many people particularly keen on dropping out, and getting onto the free ride bus.

This isn't a plan of action that someone is likely going to advertise.

Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by lazyasciiart on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:36PM (#20423169)
Disregarding the factual issues there, what about the moral hazard of not doing so and turning people into Safe Seattle members who literally advocate shooting them or driving them into the forest and leaving them there?
Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by rdtwo on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:56PM (#20423348)
Honestly the housing first is a bad idea for the visibly homeless. Might work Ok for the invisible homelessness but the property damage costs can easily be factors lager than even the rent cost.
Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by WhatIsDukkha on Friday July 12, 2019 @05:44PM (#20424794)
Citation needed.

I think you should seriously reconsider your position.

There is a chronic inebriate apartment building downtown Seattle that makes no moral judgements about "stopping drinking" etc that LOWERS COSTS (with studies to back it up) for the community.

People with problems get a permanent address. Ambulance and police calls drop as they aren't chasing these guys all over town.

Think again.

MAYBE your position is more about being judgemental about their moral state then actually whats good for them and the rest of us.

EDIT -

Just to be clear. If someone is too far gone (and many of these guys are) then we need to start funding involutanry commitment beds.

Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by rdtwo on Saturday July 13, 2019 @04:24PM (#20429947)
Might be marginally effective but at what cost. If it costs more a year to house one of the chronically homeless than incarcerate then then I’d go with the cheaper option. The money is better used to help the invisible homeless after that point
Re:Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving M... by fasthandle on Saturday July 13, 2019 @02:14AM (#20426754)
Wealthy part of the richest country in the world cannot home it's citizens because NIMBY property prices?