Now I'm not totally convinced that they are inseperable, moreover I'd say that even had Google done the "walled garden" method they'd still not have the clout and balls to fight the carriers like Apple did/does (who else could?). That all said, though, in the larger dialogue comparing the smartphone philosophies of Google and Apple where things like open and closed are used mostly as inaccurate rhetoric tools the empirical evidence that carriers add a bunch of often undesirable drift to most phones they carry is a huge punch to Android and it's easy to scramble to explain it away as an open/closed effect. Whatever that means.
One interesting point Siegler didn't make is that Google is making some modest strides toward weakening the carriers' grip on the handset market (e.g. selling Nexus One unlocked themselves, and Nexus S unlocked through vendors). Sure, they're niche devices and the Nexus One direct sales model didn't work out that well, but they're testing the water. I'm pretty sure their goal there is to increase general consumer acceptance of buying unlocked, carrier-untouched phones. And that helps every smartphone maker, perhaps especially Apple (who probably stand the best chance of selling large numbers of $600 handsets without carrier subsidy).
Apple themselves could have made this play, by offering (and promoting) the iPhone unlocked at launch (or since), but they chose instead to work with the carriers (a reasonable decision to maximise short-term success).
1. Just because currently the "carrier subsidized phone" model is the working one, it a. doesn't mean this will continue once the smartphone is prevalent and people start to understand the use cases and b. may actually be more about carrier lock in that seeding the market.[1]
2. Closed and open and well defined. Quit pretending they are not well understood terms -- fuzzy edges does not mean the whole term is useless.[2]
3. The part where you commentgasm about apple experiences makes me suspect you are astroturfing. Or even worse, are a goddamn fanboi
[1] This is wooly thinking, when you don't consider completely reasonable alternatives. More or less by definition. +
[2] This is disingenuous thinking, once again by definition. +
+ Obviously you are just trolling with your hypocrisy.
Also, that's the first time I've been called an Apple fanboy. In fact given my concluding paragraph I'm amused you could draw that conclusion. (FWIW I don't own a single Apple product.)
This is just incredibly woolly thinking, if not actually disingenuous.
Carriers have power to influence or dictate handset features because carrier promotions are the primary means of distribution for handsets, because they (not the handset manufacturers) own the consumer relationship, and because carrier subsidies are the only way anyone but power users will buy any but the cheapest phones. (This is true in the UK, and seems to be even more true in the US.) They'll exercise that power in some way.
In the case of dumbphones they do so by having their own brand dominate the manufacturer's, so consumers associate with their carrier instead of their handset manufacturer.
With "closed" smartphones (whatever "open" and "closed" mean, but let's assume the iPhone is "closed") they used to do so by only allowing customised and branded variants of the phones onto their networks. The iPhone was the first carrier-sold smartphone to take a stand against carrier customisation. This is one explanation for why the iPhone was so successful: most people's experience with every previous smartphone was actually of variants loaded with carrier crapware.
The iPhone is a desirable handset, and Apple has the marketing skills and brand to reach consumers directly, which takes back some of the bargaining power from the carriers, but it's hardly out from under their yoke. Most obvious piece of evidence: AT&T exclusivity in the US. The features you can use over WLAN but not 3G are also very likely to be carrier-influenced.
So how exactly does the "openness" of Android, whatever that means, help the carriers? They can read the source code... but why bother when they can dictate features directly to the handset manufacturers? They can install apps on the phones, even write custom apps... oh wait, they were doing that already. It's plausible Android might ship with some nicely documented compiler flags for carriers to switch off the features they don't want, rather than their engineers having to actually dive into the source drop they got from the handset manufacturer and disable the features themselves, but other smartphone platforms have been doing that for the last ten years - and anyway nobody is claiming Android is open because of its nicely documented feature killswitches.
The actual situation is that Android phones are getting loaded with carrier crapware and nerfs not because they're "open" (whatever that means), but because that's what's happened to all phones throughout history. The iPhone is an exception to some extent, not because it's "closed" (whatever that means), but because of Apple's ingenious strategy of actually giving a shit about the user experience, not to mention their world-class marketing department. The only way this ridiculous TechCrunchism makes any sense at all is if you're not really talking about "closed" vs "open", but "iPhone" vs "not iPhone".
So although the author protests that he has no skin in the game, this silly argument is actually yet another instance of the standard fanboy cry: "Why won't all these other handset companies just admit that Apple has won, and move into some other industry like flowerpots?" (Which is pretty irritating to anyone who doesn't think the game is over yet.)