News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Telling Right From Wrong by joe_the_user on Sunday December 26, 2010 @05:17PM (#2041273)
Building a plausible a-religious moral philosophy always reminded me of building a plausible perpetual motion machine.

How can you conceal the fact that you're trying to extract a conclusion from a system that doesn't have a premise? Well, there are indeed lots of methods of misdirection.

The last try at building a perpetual motion machine that I remember involved claiming to have a device for "amplifying power" but not being able to hook the device to itself "somehow". Made the system harder to disprove.

Re:Telling Right From Wrong by rue on Sunday December 26, 2010 @07:38PM (#2041479)
A religious basis doesn't make a moral philosophy any more reasonable (you can't argue real divine inspiration without proof). I am not sure if you even intended to imply that, of course.

A "scientific" moral philosophy is still rooted in some fundamental non-objective rule, of course, but that's not necessarily a bad thing nor does it affect its plausibility.

One fundamental is that humans are separated from other animals[1] not just by self-awareness but also awareness of others — and the resulting effect of empathy. With this information, it can be argued that this ability bestows an obligation to care for others. A consistent moral philosophy can be built from that and other observations.

[1] This could apply to equal or lesser degree to some other species but we have no way of verifying it currently.

Re:Telling Right From Wrong by Herring on Sunday December 26, 2010 @06:13PM (#2041354)
Building a moral system from premises always reminded me of Data in star trek trying to understand emotions logically. It just doesn't work that way. Every culture has a system of morality, even apes have a strong sense of fairness. And one would have to be very ignorant of the bible (or any religious text i've seen) to think morals come from it.
Re:Telling Right From Wrong by Locke1689 on Monday December 27, 2010 @03:03AM (#2042050)
Ick. Sounds like you need to read a bit more about epistemology. After you have torn everything apart you get a more solid grasp of how to build some semblance of a system up again.

Here's my suggested reading list: Plato to establish a foundation, Descartes's First Meditation (edit: or the skeptics, but I don't really feel the need to subject non-philosophy students to that) to tear it down, Kant to give you a more rounded view (but be careful to note where Kant fails as well), Hume to bring reasonableness into being, Nietzsche to round out the pitfalls of nihilism, and some Neo-Kantianism, evolutionary psychology, and modern ethics to round it out.

Re:Telling Right From Wrong by chc on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:59AM (#2042044)
I don't see why a secular moral philosophy is necessarily any more lacking in a premise than a religious one. Unless we're defining "areligious" to mean "without a premise," in which case I suppose it is tautological.
Re:Telling Right From Wrong by jemfinch on Sunday December 26, 2010 @10:00PM (#2041704)
Religion is a subset of metaphysics. Ethics is a subset of metaphysics. Neither is a subset of the other. I don't understand your objection to ethical claims unfounded in religion.
Re:Telling Right From Wrong by unoti on Monday December 27, 2010 @12:00AM (#2041865)
> Building a plausible a-religious moral philosophy...

You should definitely read Anathem by Neal Stephenson! He does exactly that, and a lot of other things.