News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by okmokmz on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @12:14PM (#20403365)
>To me, category 3 is the most dangerous. Tech workers have a responsibility not just understand the technologies that they work with, but also educate themselves on the societal implications of those technologies. And as others have pointed out, this extends beyond home speakers to any voice-enabled device in general.

Yes I'm frequently amazed how many coworkers I have that are still completely plugged into Google, Facebook, Amazon services/spyware, fill their homes with internet enabled "smart devices", have alexa/google assistance etc, and yet they act like I'm paranoid when I try to discuss security concerns or just flat out don't care.

As much as I hate to say it, I think there needs to be a massive breach or abuse of power from one of these organizations/services that has severe real world consequences for those that utilize/support them. Until then nothing will change.

Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by Godel_unicode on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @12:30PM (#20403534)
It sounds like you're hoping for this as evidence that you were right to be concerned; have you considered that you might be wrong? What if your coworkers are right, and the risk is actually extremely low? How would you determine that?
Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by roenxi on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @10:44PM (#20408711)
> It sounds like you're hoping for this as evidence that you were right to be concerned; have you considered that you might be wrong?

An alternate interpretation is that if a massive breach of trust is intentional then it would be better if it happened sooner rather than later.

> What if your coworkers are right...? How would you determine that?

That is a pretty classic appeal to popularity; what most co-workers believe is not evidence of anything in this case. If they are right, they are right. If they are wrong, they might be a self-selected group of the people who don't see a risk for what it is.

At any rate 'the risk' is a bit vague, but moral panics and witch hunts are things that happen. When the tech companies get involved in one, which will happen, it could be very nasty. There is clearly some sort of new risk here making it easier to quickly and accurately identify minorities. Even ignoring rogue employees finding creative ways to use data to enrich themselves.

Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by okmokmz on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @12:45PM (#20403723)
>It sounds like you're hoping for this as evidence that you were right to be concerned

Not at all, if the constant security breaches and lack of response from consumers, regulators, companies, etc. isn't enough evidence for you that there is a serious problem then you fall into the group I'm describing

Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by joshuamorton on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @01:55PM (#20404518)
What constant security breaches? There are two major examples of security breaches I can think of that happened recently at amagoofaceoft: mis-stored passwords (fb/insta, and google for a short period earlier this year), and variants of the Cambridge analytics attacks, which steal public information but at scale. While those certainly aren't good, I wouldn't classify either as a security breach. The first was a loss of defense in depth, and the second, like I said, just got public info, but lots of it.

Are you saying that breaches at other companies mean we shouldn't trust the big ones to be secure? Like because Equifax has terrible security practice, google by definition must also have bad security? Or...what?

(I work at Google).

Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by okmokmz on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @02:09PM (#20404656)
Breaches was probably the wrong term to use in my example, as it brings attention to the wrong issue. The point I am trying to make is not that we shouldn't trust large companies to be secure as you say (although based on my experience with enterprise infosec I wouldn't be surprised if a majority of companies handling/storing personal data don't have appropriate security controls enforced).

The point I am making is that many large organizations such as Google and Facebook are performing worldwide, largely unchecked mass surveillance with data collection and analytical capabilities far beyond what is available to the majority of the world, and people simply don't care despite how knowledgeable they are about technology. There's also little to now way to escape it as Google and Facebook technology is so ingrained in the existing internet. While Google may not have poor security practices and may never experience a breach where data is stolen (although again I highly doubt that), as far as I'm concerned Google itself, as well as Facebook, are malicious actors in my own life and personal opsec as a huge portion of their business model is based on collecting and monetizing user data by any means possible with little to no concern for the negative impact on users such as mental health problems.

Frankly, I don't like companies that make money spying on people, particularly those that abuse psychological techniques that make it more difficult for people to make informed decisions or choices about the technology they're using.

Beyond that, these technologies are sold/rented or otherwise provided to governments, law enforcement and intelligence agencies, dictators, authoritarian regimes, and others that can and are being for personal gain.

So no, I don't believe we should trust Google, but not because other companies have experienced data breaches. That is just one of the many reasons I believe people should value their data and personal privacy far more than most do

Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by okmokmz on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:07PM (#20414497)
I find it funny that I often get defensive questions from Google and Facebook engineers about their technologies/organizations when I post initial pro-privacy comments on HN, but after being called out and explaining in more detail I never get a response. I guess there's no point for them to argue it further as they're aware of the negative impact, but have made a conscious decision to choose money over morals
Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by Godel_unicode on Thursday July 11, 2019 @05:32PM (#20416068)
You said they have constant breaches, then immediately recanted when asked for details. Your argument which got no reply was an idealogical argument which appears to be constructed to shut down debate (they shouldn't be trusted because you don't like them) as opposed to lead to a meaningful discussion. You even threw out the casual line about them not having poor security and breaches, invalidating your argument in the post they replied to.

In other words, they seemingly care about whether the technical argument has merits. Once it's clear that there's no technical substance and it moves on to your personal crusade against modern companies, people lose interest.

Disclaimer: I don't work anywhere near the companies in question

Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by okmokmz on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @11:48AM (#20460740)
>You said they have constant breaches, then immediately recanted when asked for details

No, I didn't, go back and read again

>Your argument which got no reply was an idealogical argument which appears to be constructed to shut down debate

It wasn't meant to shut down debate. If he wants to argue the ethics of spying on people and using psychological tactics for financial gain I'd be more than happy to discuss

>You even threw out the casual line about them not having poor security and breaches, invalidating your argument in the post they replied to

Again, no I didn't. I never said google had poor security or breaches, and I clearly stated that was just a generic example I used which brings attention to the wrong things, as demonstrated by you focusing on "breaches" rather than the point I was really trying to make and elucidated in my reply.

>In other words, they seemingly care about whether the technical argument has merits. Once it's clear that there's no technical substance and it moves on to your personal crusade against modern companies, people lose interest.

That's the entire point, and why I regretted saying "breaches". You are focusing 100% on the wrong thing. The problem that I have is not a technical argument about whether or not breaches could occur

Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by joshuamorton on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:59AM (#20418595)
As the original person, this almost exactly. I can totally understand why someone might hold those opinions. I don't share them, and argument won't be productive. Litigating values doesn't get anywhere.
Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by jhayward on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @02:02PM (#20404586)
> Are you saying that breaches at other companies mean we shouldn't trust the big ones to be secure? Like because Equifax has terrible security practice, google by definition must also have bad security? Or...what?

Are you asserting that Google detects 100% of significant breaches, and promptly notifies the public of all of them?

My experience tells me that neither assertion is likely to be true.

Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by SolaceQuantum on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @01:10PM (#20403985)
"... I think there needs to be a massive breach or abuse of power from one of these organizations/services that has severe real world consequences for those that utilize/support them..."

One of my greater fears is the knowledge that, should this happen, there's a nonzero chance that no one would care.

Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by jgroszko on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @01:44PM (#20404380)
I suppose it hasn't had mass real world consequences for folks yet, but the Equifax breach pretty much proves this?
Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by okmokmz on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @01:55PM (#20404517)
Yes, the Equifax breach is one of the reasons I included "severe" as a qualifier. It has been demonstrated that even fairly serious breaches will be ignored by the general public. It needs to be something that makes people genuinely fear for the safety of their finances, possessions, and/or health
Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by inetknght on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @12:35PM (#20403596)
> there needs to be a massive breach or abuse of power from one of these organizations/services that has severe real world consequences for those that utilize/support them. Until then nothing will change.

I think even more darkly: that the consequences of something severe enough to cause that change would be so much as to effectively destroy modern civilization. Consider that much of the modern economy is driven by tech companies not only ignoring privacy but often actively violating it.