News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by ethbro on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @11:50AM (#20403112)
I like that matrix!

One thing that I think gets lost in engineers (and humans) is scale.

Googazon doing {thing} might be "meh" for 10 people. But the implications look very different when it's doing {thing} for 10%+ of a country's population.

At 10 people, I may find out Ted likes to eat Italian. At 10%, I may find out an Italian chain has a sudden health issue and short their stock.

Which is in essence their original playbook: do things that only work at a scale that only we can play at.

Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by jancsika on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @12:40PM (#20403671)
> At 10%, I may find out an Italian chain has a sudden health issue and short their stock.

Let's use scale at both ends please.

At 10% of the population a nation state may ask Googazon to silently make changes to identify troublemakers.

Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by ben_w on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @01:26PM (#20404195)
Here’s an entirely plausible scenario:

The person in the story said they thought they heard domestic violence in some of the recordings.

I know some people who are into “consensual nonconsent“, a form of BDSM which I do not understand, but as these acquaintances tell me they like being on the receiving end I have reason to trust them.

Any system or person which incorrectly identifies one of these groups as the other, in either direction, has life-altering negative consequences. Note that in the UK, some forms of consensual BDSM have been prosecuted as serious assault, and the person on the receiving end has been prosecuted for conspiracy to commit assault because they consented to it.

Any system which prevents DV information reaching the police is bad. Any system which reports BDSM to the police as DV is bad. I don’t even know what the relative frequencies of the two acts are, so I cannot even make a utilitarian ethical judgement.

Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by outworlder on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @05:35PM (#20406827)
> Note that in the UK, some forms of consensual BDSM have been prosecuted as serious assault, and the person on the receiving end has been prosecuted for conspiracy to commit assault because they consented to it.

Can someone versed in UK law clarify how such a stupid system emerged out of their laws? I'd guess that's an unintended consequence of how laws were worded, but it is mind boggling.

Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by Angostura on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @07:08PM (#20407517)
I'm not versed in UK law, but live in the UK and am aware of a few cases. Bottom line - British law does not recognize the possibility of consenting to actual bodily harm.

I'm not aware of any recent case where the person on the receiving end was prosecuted for consenting, perhaps the OC can cast some light on that.

Re:Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations by ben_w on Thursday July 11, 2019 @04:13AM (#20409937)
My acquaintances mostly reference Operation Spanner which is about 30 years old now. I don’t know if that counts as recent or not, however while the Law Commission recommended in 1994(!) that this law be altered, it appears their recommendation was never adopted.