Re:Prof. Ross Anderson's response to a takedown request abou...
by jmaygarden on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @04:28PM
(#2046872)
That kind of ruling just turns my stomach. The court used a an enumerated power--that was primarily intended to prevent tariffs being erected between the states--to effectively remove all limits to federal power. Gonzales v. Raich (2005)[1] is analogous to the Wickard v. Filburn case that you cite. In his dissent, Justice Thomas said the following:
If the Federal Government can regulate growing a half-dozen cannabis plants for personal
consumption (not because it is interstate commerce, but because it is inextricably bound up
with interstate commerce), then Congress' Article I powers -- as expanded by the Necessary
and Proper Clause -- have no meaningful limits. Whether Congress aims at the possession of
drugs, guns, or any number of other items, it may continue to "appropria[te] state police
powers under the guise of regulating commerce."
[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gonzales_v._Raich
Again, I mention this without endorsement of either side; I mention this just because I only recently learned about this myself.
[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn