News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dell E7440 and E7240 Hackintosh by yumraj on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @05:40PM (#20396938)
The one issue I've always had with Hackintosh, is that while the main OS is from Apple it invariably requires using some 3rd party bootloaders, kexts and other files. And, this to me always raises the issue of security and whether they contain, or can contain, any backdoors/malwares.

Part of it could be my paranioa, but I never got a good answer to satisfy me.

Re:Dell E7440 and E7240 Hackintosh by neilv on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @06:13PM (#20397209)
Most of the alternative Android distros/builds (other than for devices supported by LineageOS at the moment) have similar provenance problems, in my experience with many devices: XDA-developers usually told me to just download and run/install these binaries from some strange file-sharing site. Not only is that highly questionable practice, but it seems to relieve much of the demand for more reasonable solutions. Which is one of the reasons I'm hoping PostmarketOS takes off -- a lot of the sketchiness potential has been removed.
Re:Dell E7440 and E7240 Hackintosh by wtallis on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @06:28PM (#20397356)
This tends to also apply to OpenWRT vs almost all other third-party router firmware distributions. But at least for router distros, some of the maintainers of custom builds earn a fairly solid reputation and eventually build a project that approaches the degree of organization that's typical for desktop Linux distros. I think phone OS distros have to change targets too often the really get there.
Re:Dell E7440 and E7240 Hackintosh by neilv on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @06:33PM (#20397393)
Good point. The Linux ecosystem is much more amenable to that than chasing whatever Android does. Also, the popular home router hardware is more amenable than most handhelds (which often locked bootloaders, signed images, and lots of unsustainable closed drivers).
Re:Dell E7440 and E7240 Hackintosh by yumraj on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @07:03PM (#20397641)
For my DD-WRT build I struggled in a similar way, since a compromised router can do a lot of damage. In the end it seemed "kong" had a good reputation and decided to get his/her build, but it wasn't an easy decision.
Re:Dell E7440 and E7240 Hackintosh by the8472 on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @06:00PM (#20397104)
How is that all that different from any other software you download? With 100s of dependencies any one of them could be malicious and just wait for the next privilege escalation attack and achieve the same persistence level as a malicious kernel module.
Re:Dell E7440 and E7240 Hackintosh by rwmj on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @06:43AM (#20400722)
The major Linux distros have processes in place to both filter what goes in and handle security issues when they happen. If you have specific concerns then name them, but downloading a Fedora or Debian install is in no way comparable to installing binaries from random filesharing websites.
Re:Dell E7440 and E7240 Hackintosh by la_barba on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @04:45PM (#20406344)
>but downloading a Fedora or Debian install is in no way comparable to installing binaries from random filesharing websites.

What if you download binaries from non-random, trusted websites? Seem to me that is the same as trusting a repo maintainer.

Re:Dell E7440 and E7240 Hackintosh by rwmj on Thursday July 11, 2019 @06:48AM (#20410554)
You omitted where I said distros "have processes in place". We can discuss whether the processes are adequate, but the situation itself is completely different from downloading binaries from websites, trusted or otherwise.
Re:Dell E7440 and E7240 Hackintosh by la_barba on Thursday July 11, 2019 @11:37AM (#20412367)
I don't think its "completely different". Its only a minor difference in my view. We'll just have to agree to disagree. IMO repository maintainers are not going to code review every patch in every package, and logistically they can't anyway. The only 'process' here AFAICT, is to take down the patch once news spreads of a bad patch.
Re:Dell E7440 and E7240 Hackintosh by the8472 on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @08:30AM (#20401295)
Do you only run software available in distro packages?
Re:Dell E7440 and E7240 Hackintosh by rwmj on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @08:35AM (#20401334)
Given that I'm a Fedora packager, yes, or else software which I wrote myself.
Re:Dell E7440 and E7240 Hackintosh by burtonator on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @05:50PM (#20397031)
I put in some malware in kext directly targeting anyone named yumraj. /evilgrin