Re:A list of Amazon’s businesses and subsidiaries
by LudwigNagasena on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @04:40AM
(#20389951)
Does India not have any anti-dumping / pro-competition laws?
Re:A list of Amazon’s businesses and subsidiaries
by notmyaccount on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @07:15AM
(#20390656)
The All India Online Vendors Association (AIOVA), which represents more than 3,500 online sellers did file a complaint against Flipkart/Amazon with Competition Commission of India (CCI) however, CCI did not find any violation of existing laws in Amazon or Flipkarts trade practices. IANAL but India does have Anti-Dumping and Pro-Competition laws but probably they are not updated for e-commerce. Amazon and Flipkart are able to find loop holes in it to continue their practices. Which is why Govt. imposed the marketplace cannot sell the products laws.
For Food delivery, the Restaurant Association is discussing the matter with Govt. Agencies. This article would be able to explain laws better : http://www.mondaq.com/india/x/808174/Antitrust+Competition/C...
For example, a smartphone that sells at $400 at offline stores would be available for $350 on Amazon/Flipkart. The cost price of device would be $350 for offline stores. You can also use No Cost financing to purchase the product for monthly payment of $58.33 for 6 months (Totaling $350). Amazon/Flipkart would absorb the interest cost. The losses are obvious as neither Amazon India Inc. (opened 2013) nor Flipkart (opened 2007 and the biggest Indian marketplace bought by Walmart in 2018 for $16 Billion) have made a cent of profit in India. Both Flipkart and Amazon had losses around $500 million for FY17-18, a number expected to go up post Walmart's purchase of Flipkart. Also, Amazon Prime is India is available for $15 a year and includes Amazon Prime Video, Amazon Prime Music and 1 Day Free Standard Shipping with no minimum order. In a country where data is basically free (30GB 4G Data with unlimited calls/messages per month for $2), this also adds to pushing people towards Amazon.
On a seperate note, a similar thing is taking place in Indian food delivery market where food delivery companies like Zomato, Swiggy or Ubereats are offering steep continuous discounts of 40-60% forcing delivery restaurants to jump into their ecosystem. The Restaurant association has also approached government with their complaints.
For Example, a Sub that sells for $4 would be delivered for $2 including delivery cost. The delivery companies absorbing rest of the costs.