News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blindsided by a Devastating Veto, Alaska University Syste... by peteradio on Monday July 08, 2019 @12:47PM (#20384279)
I don't think the disparity was expected and doubt the founders would conclude that sparsely populated states with very little economy should lead an entire branch. This is certainly not working.
Re:Blindsided by a Devastating Veto, Alaska University Syste... by logfromblammo on Monday July 08, 2019 @01:27PM (#20384748)
How about representation proportional to economic activity instead of the quantity of state-ness being one or zero? With guaranteed representation of at least one seat, so the representation turns out to be slightly skewed against the powerhouses. Also note that Puerto Rico and Washington DC earn their seat by virtue of having enough economic activity, rather than by default.

"Seats" is senate seats per state; "rep" is proportion of total representation; "econ" is proportion of total economic activity.

I picked 150 for the total number of seats to make the rep vs. econ gap narrower, but not so much as to make the poorest 25 completely irrelevant.

  state         seats    rep   econ
  ---------------------------------
  California       20  13.3%  14.5%
  Texas            12   8.0%   8.7%
  New York         11   7.3%   8.2%
  Florida           7   4.7%   5.1%
  Illinois          6   4.0%   4.2%

  PA OH          }- 5   6.7%   7.1%

  NJ GA WA MA NC }- 4  18.7%  19.5%
  VA MI          }

  MD CO MN TN IN }- 3  10.0%   9.2%

  AZ WI MI CT LA }- 2  10.7%  10.7%
  OR SC AL       }

  KY OK IA UT KS }
  NV DC AK NE MS }
  PR NM HI NH WV }- 1  16.7%  12.5%
  ID DE ME RI ND }
  AK SD MO WY VT }

  island terr.   }- 0   0.0%   0.1%
  ---------------------------------
  Total           150
Re:Blindsided by a Devastating Veto, Alaska University Syste... by Nasrudith on Monday July 08, 2019 @04:04PM (#20386251)
Economic activity would be a bad choice to tie to representation from perverse incentives. It would encourage outright sabotaging other states to preserve power when it would be more optimal to go with national net economic output instead of "best for my region". Essentially the same issues as regulatory capture but worse. It is also why auctioning off positions of power for fundraising would be a terrible idea - it encourages the biggest vested interest to buy it up and exploit it at the cost of everyone else.
Re:Blindsided by a Devastating Veto, Alaska University Syste... by logfromblammo on Monday July 08, 2019 @05:13PM (#20386818)
It doesn't have to be a good choice; it just has to be better than "two per state, no matter what".

The perverse incentive there encourages secession, state-splitting, endless intractable battles over Puerto Rican statehood or DC representation, and engineering politics at the state level to influence interstate migrations based partly on political views on national issues.

I.e. Colorado decriminalizes recreational cannabis, and Alabama recriminalizes abortion. Lefties are incentivized to move from AL to CO, and righties the reverse. Everybody who voted Doug Jones leaves for literally greener pastures, and mall-menace Roy Moore wins the seat.

(Anecdotally, one of my co-workers is moving to Denver, and I have realized I am envious.)

It further incentivizes politically competitive states to do anything for just 0.1% of the vote, because that might just be the margin that gets you all the power, for six whole years, on election day.

Re:Blindsided by a Devastating Veto, Alaska University Syste... by peteradio on Monday July 08, 2019 @01:39PM (#20384867)
What is column 1 and 2 with the numbers?
Re:Blindsided by a Devastating Veto, Alaska University Syste... by fwip on Monday July 08, 2019 @03:23PM (#20385872)
The first number column is "seats per state". The second number column is "combined percentage of representatives" - PA and OH each have 5 representatives, so combined they have (5+5)/150 = 6.7% of the representation. The third column is, I presume, the percentage of economic activity (GDP?) totaled among those states.
Re:Blindsided by a Devastating Veto, Alaska University Syste... by mdorazio on Monday July 08, 2019 @01:04PM (#20384457)
Had to look up the stats on this. Around the time the constitution was written, about 5% of the US population lived in cities. It's over 80% today. I think the intent of having the Senate represent the states equally regardless of population was a good one, but the massive shift in demographics over the last 200 years probably merits a different approach.

I don't think going strictly by population density is the best approach either, though - that's a good way to completely alienate millions of Americans. Remember that the two branches of Congress were setup like this to force urban and rural communities to work together and compromise. The problem now is that tribalism has become so rampant on both sides that compromise no longer really happens.

Re:Blindsided by a Devastating Veto, Alaska University Syste... by peteradio on Monday July 08, 2019 @01:20PM (#20384657)
What was the economy difference between founding states? I don't care about rural urban divide. I care about states that can effectively be purchased by a rich individual having same say as states with country sized economies. At the time of founding individual states were bringing something to the table.
Re:Blindsided by a Devastating Veto, Alaska University Syste... by mdorazio on Monday July 08, 2019 @01:43PM (#20384920)
We could look at state-level GDP as one measure, but I don't think it's as clear-cut as you think - see [1]. There's a significant amount of money in farming, livestock, and manufacturing, which tend to cluster in "cheap" states. I think you make a good point about concentration of wealth at the state level, though. There's probably a case to be made that rural states are more susceptible to control by a few individuals/corporations that make up large segments of the state's economic output. It's worth noting that economic inequality is usually higher in states with bigger economies, though [2].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_and_territ...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_Gini_co...

Re:Blindsided by a Devastating Veto, Alaska University Syste... by slowmovintarget on Monday July 08, 2019 @05:20PM (#20386873)
The disparity was expected and that is part of the reason that the House of Representatives is based on population.