Re:The death watch for the X Window System has probably started
by vondur on Sunday July 07, 2019 @08:12PM
(#20378903)
I wonder why the SGI stuff for X was not open sourced?
Re:The death watch for the X Window System has probably started
by p_l on Sunday July 07, 2019 @09:39PM
(#20379287)
very tightly integrated with Irix and SGI MIPS hardware, from my understanding.
A bit like IRIS GL never getting open sourced, because it wouldn't be of much use without matching hardware exposed over /dev/GL interface.
Over time, a lot of useful stuff was broken and supported less and less, then reimplemented in bad way over compositors, instead of having composting Xserver like Xsgi.
Security extensions or even basic security tools (private input grab) got waylaid because toolkits didn't implement them (try running GTK3 on hardware without 32bit color GL or on system that defaults to lower bit depth than 32/24).
Generally, after letting it get more and more broken, the suggestion for big rewrite arrived. Said suggestion often results in something that resembles "devs first graphic stack", with a lot of basic, important features for daily life relegated to "someone will make an extension for it later" or "use D-bus to implement it elsewhere, and who cares about compatibility".