Re:Testing is waste of time, I know that my code works
by srean on Friday December 24, 2010 @01:09PM
(#2037697)
My beef against testing is that I often see it adopted (and often subtly pushed) as an alternative to thinking through the logic carefully -- Why mess with the if statements, my tests will catch the errors if any. Should I index the array with i or i+1 ? I will just test what works. Should I loop till n-1 or n-2. Let me just stick with n-2 and add a test...
The problem is that to write tests that really ensure that the logic is correct you really need to think through the logic really hard. Just spraying the code with a few tests that happen to come to the mind is not enough.
I am yet to see a convincing argument that shows that coming up with a sufficient number of (unit)tests from a specification is any easier than getting the logic right.
Testing is well intentioned but often abused as an excuse to be sloppy.
The problem is that to write tests that really ensure that the logic is correct you really need to think through the logic really hard. Just spraying the code with a few tests that happen to come to the mind is not enough.
I am yet to see a convincing argument that shows that coming up with a sufficient number of (unit)tests from a specification is any easier than getting the logic right.
Testing is well intentioned but often abused as an excuse to be sloppy.