The point being: a large fraction of the population in the US is living paycheck to paycheck and has no money to spare for investing in an index fund.
being poor impairs your cognition[1], so it's not surprising that they are wasting money on stuff like that.
[1] random google result: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-poverty-affec...
And if you were to find evidence of poorer people having impaired decision-making skills in the US (and there might be evidence of that), the question becomes, are they as poor as they are because of that poor decision making?
If they're forced to take their money out of the fund due to their circumstances, then they could actually lose a lot of it (an economic downturn makes both situations more likely to occur at the same time). Whereas someone who is well off only loses money on paper and can afford to hold on to their investment until the economy improves.
In short, index funds are a bad investment unless you're well off enough that you won't need the money invested. At least not for a long time.
Contrast that with the plethora of wealth-increasing opportunities that are not available without a large initial investment or the connections or power that comes with existing wealth.