News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EASA demands additional changes for the 737 Max by jhayward on Saturday July 06, 2019 @01:56PM (#20370881)
You should probably not fly any 737, then, because it's had just as many bad, bad design flaws that killed people. Oh, and it's also the most successful commercial aircraft in history.
Re:EASA demands additional changes for the 737 Max by hugi on Saturday July 06, 2019 @04:09PM (#20371620)
What are you talking about? The crash rate of the MAX is about 13 times higher than that of other 737 models combined.
Re:EASA demands additional changes for the 737 Max by jhayward on Saturday July 06, 2019 @04:47PM (#20371848)
It doesn't have the crash rate now. At one time early in its introduction it had a very bad crash rate. Which is my point.
Re:EASA demands additional changes for the 737 Max by hugi on Saturday July 06, 2019 @04:52PM (#20371871)
That's just plain wrong. The crash rates of the older 737 don't even approach the 737 MAX, which is an outlier.

https://i.imgur.com/lLLeldA.png

Source: https://qz.com/1571820/deaths-on-the-boeing-737-max-8-vs-oth...

Re:EASA demands additional changes for the 737 Max by fromthestart on Saturday July 06, 2019 @05:07PM (#20371970)
That's pretty misleading. The image is looking at cumulative fatalities over a period, and those planes are all different sizes.

The question here is likelihood of fatal accident, which is not addressed by your source.

Re:EASA demands additional changes for the 737 Max by hugi on Saturday July 06, 2019 @05:20PM (#20372039)
Can you show me the numbers you're talking about?
Re:EASA demands additional changes for the 737 Max by jhayward on Saturday July 06, 2019 @05:22PM (#20372045)
Those are fatalities, not crashes.

They had the exact same number of crashes, plus one near-crash. Very similar to me. Planes flew with much lower passenger loads in those days so total fatalities can differ.

I don't know what the exact crash rate (i.e., % flights that end in hull loss) was.

Re:EASA demands additional changes for the 737 Max by hugi on Saturday July 06, 2019 @05:25PM (#20372064)
Please show data.
Re:EASA demands additional changes for the 737 Max by jhayward on Saturday July 06, 2019 @05:38PM (#20372137)
It's actually worse that I stated: 2 confirmed fatal crashes, 1 severe malfunction in-flight, 4 fatal crashes that are most likely same cause, and two more in-flight loss of control incidents that are likely same.

That's just what's on the wiki page [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_737_rudder_issues

Re:EASA demands additional changes for the 737 Max by hugi on Saturday July 06, 2019 @06:44PM (#20372487)
That's all in the 90's. You said "early in its introduction".

I provided a list of fatalities, you said that was a bad measure and early 737 was a worse plane that crashed more often. Do you have stats for that?

Re:EASA demands additional changes for the 737 Max by jhayward on Saturday July 06, 2019 @07:27PM (#20372657)
It's pretty clear you aren't actually interested in obtaining a balanced view of design flaws in aircraft, rather just trying to win some kind of points.

Some design flaws take time to show up, due to life cycle aging. Most of the rudder issues were in 737-300's, which began full production in the mid-1980s. There isn't just a single "737" model, even for the same 737-XXX series.

You can do your own research from here on out. If 6 fatal crashes plus non-fatal incidents due to the same design flaw don't persuade you then perhaps you are not persuadable.

The basic fact, that there are plenty of previous cases of serious design flaws in aircraft that became quite safe, is sound, whether you choose to accept that or not.

Re:EASA demands additional changes for the 737 Max by mantap on Saturday July 06, 2019 @02:39PM (#20371103)
The 737 had those rudder issues but it didn't have the incompetent design of the 737 MAX.
Re:EASA demands additional changes for the 737 Max by jhayward on Saturday July 06, 2019 @04:48PM (#20371855)
I'm not sure the plane loads of passengers killed would agree with your professional opinion of design competence.

Edited to add: the rudder design was "new" to the industry, in that it had a single control surface activated by a single control mechanism with no redundancy (sound familiar?). The rudder control valve in question had been found to malfunction on 747-200's earlier and was replaced in the entire 747 fleet. The 737's were not replaced until after more fatalities.

The point of all this is that there are "incompetence" narratives that can be woven around all major design issues in commercial aircraft. To say "I'll ever fly one" displays a lack of understanding of what makes commercial aviation the safest way to travel, and what the risks actually are.

Re:EASA demands additional changes for the 737 Max by mantap on Saturday July 06, 2019 @11:15PM (#20373382)
The point is that the MAX design flaw is so shallow. It uses a single sensor. If the sensor malfunctions during flight, then the software instructs the aircraft to dive into the ground.

No right-minded person would ever design a flight control system like that. It's not merely wrong but wrong in such a basic way, as if designed by a child.

Such a situation reasonably makes people question whether the MAX project was managed by competent individuals, which is obviously a prerequisite for many people to fly in one.

Re:EASA demands additional changes for the 737 Max by danmaz74 on Saturday July 06, 2019 @06:18PM (#20372361)
Yes, you shouldn't fly on the original 737 either. But no companies are flying that one now...