It’s really not maintaining the type certification that’s the problem, it’s the aerodynamics of the airframe. If they’d called it a 797 from the beginning it would still have needed the MCAS to get FAA approval because the insane aerodynamics mean the stick forces don’t obey the regulations for constant increase in forces approaching a stall. The MCAS isn’t there just so it can pretend to be a 737.
So yeah changing the name is only a solution if by changing the name you mean fundamentally changing every aspect of it.
I don't think you understand the regulatory regime. Changing the name, creating it as a new airframe, means total top-to-bottom re-certification. That means they can ditch all the legacy equipment and start the control system from scratch. Most of the problems with the max atm are related to systems layered atop that legacy equipment (autopilot, control surfaces etc) that cannot be swapped out without changing the type/name.
The fucking name isn’t the problem. Trying to work fuel efficiency into too small a package and ending up with something with the stall characteristics of a brick is the problem. Creating it as a “new airframe” fixes the problem only by abandoning the problem they set out to solve, which again, wasn’t “keep the name”.
If this had been the 797 from the getgo, but had tried to put those engines on any airframe that stayed that low to the ground for gate compatibility, they have still needed the MCAS because of the aerodynamics of the necessary engine placement.
Remember that the 737 is such a big seller because it has huge usage on regional routes and in smaller countries. It lands at airports where they still wheel up a set of stairs, or one of those double-decker deplaning buses. The height is a big deal for established infrastructure of customers. If it weren’t, they could have redesigned the landing gear to get the necessary engine clearance instead of fucking up the aerodynamics by moving the engines.
The height, and not the name, is the original sin from which every shitty consequence flows.
The popular way is with a T-tail and podded engines off the sides of the rear of the body. Boeing has produced such an aircraft. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_717
Another way is with a high-mounted wing. This is popular for military cargo jets, such as the C-5 and C-17.
Putting engines above the wing is an option. Boeing did it for the YC-14, Antonov did it for the An-72, VFW-Fokker did it for the 614, and Honda did it for the Hondajet.
The landing gear could have be made to stick out extra long for the takeoff and landing, but then partially retract for passenger boarding. During passenger boarding, the aircraft could even sit on the engines.
The problem with the Max is that Boeing favoured the major airlines that wanted 2010s technology in a 60s airframe. But guess what, that doesn't work, in the same way you can't turn a Thunderbird into a Tesla by "just plugging a new engine".
Not that Boeing probably didn't have a vested interest in not investing in a new airframe and preferred the lowest cost project
Now if they can call the Max the 737-2, cut the legacy crap and work around the longitudinal stability by breaking backwards compatibility (and sell the plane at a discount) they could end up with smaller losses
No, the problem with the plane was that Boeing engineered a crappy solution to a problem they had.
There were 3 major problems that I am aware of.
1) A powerful(flight control wise) automated system that relied on one source of sensor data when multiple are available.
2) The switches that disabled the automated system also disabled all electronic control for the elevator trim, making it much harder for the pilots to recover from an out of trim condition.
3) The normal elevator controls are not enough for the pilot to overcome the out of trim condition so pulling back on the yoke as far as possible would not pitch the plane up enough to regain altitude.
The only way to recover from this type of situation is to momentarily pitch the plane further downwards to take stress off of the elevator trim so the manual controls are easier to operate with your hand. You would have to do that enough times to get the plane back into a stable position, this is not always possible when the plane is already at a low altitude.
Keeping the type rating means that they needed to avoid making completely new wings or significant fuselage changes, which would require a new type rating as well.
All of that led to fitting engines in a way that caused a bunch of aerodynamics problems, which led to crappy solutions.
The economic incentives started it.
Why did they have issues with MCAS? Why did they even need MCAS again?
Because they tried to fit bigger engines onto a 60s airframe that is not fly-by-wire.
If the plane was FBW, no MCAS needed.
If the plane had a bigger ground clearance, no MCAS needed.
> The normal elevator controls are not enough for the pilot to overcome the out of trim condition
I don't think there is a plane where they are, they also move more slowly than the elevators.
A plane should be airworthy even if the majority of it's automation has suffered a casualty.
Yes, but you wouldn't need MCAS for maintaining longitudinal stability
> in it's (sic) minimally "assisted" state should demonstrate basic airworthy characteristics.
If that was the case the Max would not be certifiable, MCAS or not
MCAS was Boeing’s idea of a solution to this; command the stabilizers down to provide counter force against the stick, making it harder for the pilot to pull into the stall than pull away from it at every point.
Even if the 737NG had never existed and the 737MAX as it exists today were for some reason an all new design, it would need the MCAS counter-force to get certified as air worthy no matter how much new training pilots got. It (claims to) solve a fundamental airworthiness requirement; it is not a “737NG emulation feature” as some mistakenly believe.
The worst part for Boeing is that now under additional scrutiny more problems are being found, that begs the question what else is being missed?