News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Diseases of Affluence by Mz on Friday December 24, 2010 @03:27AM (#2036868)
Really fascinating piece. Most interesting medical paragraph in the piece:

ONE OF THE COMMON PITFALLS for clinicians who treat type two diabetes occurs when they prescribe metformin to young women. Metformin decreases insulin resistance, which helps reduce blood sugar. Insulin resistance is also what causes infertility in women with polycystic ovary syndrome, as well as type two diabetes. Often, women thought to be infertile become pregnant after taking metformin. Sometimes, of course, this delights them, but sometimes it does not. Contraception does not normally seem like one of the things diabetes doctors need to emphasize. But obesity commonly underlies infertility in women, just as it also causes the growth of facial hair. And, in men, the growth of breast tissue. Adipose tissue secretes estrogens and insulin resistance increases levels of androgens. Diabetes is overwhelmingly the most common cause of male impotence in the developed world. Men and women are designed to move, and when we do not, our immobility reduces us in every respect.

Most interesting non-medical paragraph:

THE OLDEST of the bowhead whales in the Arctic Ocean have lived for two hundred years. We know this because when they are killed and examined today, we find ivory harpoon heads lodged in their skin. The implication is that they were large enough to be hunted prior to the arrival of the Hudson Bay Company and its steel harpoon heads in the 1830s. Isotopic analysis of the whales’ eyes confirms the point: these whales were calves during the Napoleonic Wars. They are certainly the longest-lived mammals on the planet. Indeed, they may be the longest-lived complex animals of any sort.

Thank you for posting this.

Re:Diseases of Affluence by bambax on Friday December 24, 2010 @08:41AM (#2037230)
I would argue the most interesting non-medical paragraph is this one:

The Polynesians did not have lodestones with which to make compasses, and their navigation system does not emphasize the stars, but the sea itself. The different wave patterns are studied and observed, as many, improbably, as fourteen simultaneously. (...) Navigating by wave train alone, the waves were best felt with the testicles; the navigator on each canoe had a special cabin he hunkered in. The idea, however, of making sense out of an interference pattern involving more than three or four wave systems is mind-boggling. The mathematical complexity of a fourteen-source interference pattern would appear more than can be held by any human brain. Or scrotum.

And apparently, it's true!

http://www.cseg.ca/publications/recorder/2008/09sep/sep2008-...

Re:Diseases of Affluence by Mz on Friday December 24, 2010 @08:55AM (#2037245)
:-)

A) I started to say "best" but felt that would be more open to argument. So I used the phrase "most interesting" in hopes that it would be accepted that what an individual finds "most interesting" is personal.

B) I'm actually very fascinated by a lot of stuff having to do with human sexuality (though that is not really what this is about) and not terribly shy about discussing it. However, I have found that it is best to tread lightly in that regard as a woman in a male dominated forum. So I thought it best to leave out any references to testicles the article made. :-D (On previous occasions, making similar observations has resulted in downvotes here.)

I also refrained from speculating out loud about some of the causes of issues described in the article. I do have some thoughts and I read the article because it fits very nicely with my interests in getting myself well against very long odds, but what I believe to be true is very far from accepted/conventional wisdom on such topics. It often gets either ignored or downvoted here. :-/

But thank you for replying. Have an upvote. :-)

Re:Diseases of Affluence by bambax on Friday December 24, 2010 @09:38AM (#2037306)
I did refrain from asking whether this particular navigation technique contributed to the prejudice that women can't drive...

> what I believe to be true is very far from accepted/conventional wisdom on such topics. It often gets either ignored or downvoted here. :-/

I had a weird experience on HN some time ago when I tried to argue that death was actually a good thing and was immediately downvoted.

It seems people downvote comments they perceive to be "contrarian", ie insincere and artificially opposed to mainstream; the problem of course is that it's very difficult to discriminate ingenuous from disingenious contrarian opinions.

Just because one thinks different does not mean they do it on purpose. And in the end, only the truth should matter; even if a point is actually being argued disingeniously, this fact alone doesn't make it wrong...

Re:Diseases of Affluence by randallsquared on Friday December 24, 2010 @11:56AM (#2037516)
I had a weird experience on HN some time ago when I tried to argue that death was actually a good thing and was immediately downvoted.

It seems people downvote comments they perceive to be "contrarian" [...]

You should probably choose another example, since "death is necessary and ultimately a good thing" is the mainstream view, not contrarian at all.

Re:Diseases of Affluence by CapitalistCartr on Friday December 24, 2010 @07:49PM (#2038319)
I, too, have never found appreciating the upside to death a common or popular view. I'd be interested to know your social circle; it sounds much more interesting than mine.
Re:Diseases of Affluence by randallsquared on Saturday December 25, 2010 @02:09AM (#2038641)
My social circle mostly wants to live forever, but that's because I've surrounded myself with transhumanists and libertarians, who are a lot less deathist than the population in general. :)
Re:Diseases of Affluence by lkrubner on Friday December 24, 2010 @03:41PM (#2037966)
That is an astounding thing to say. I can not think of anyone that I know personally who thinks that death is a good thing. Can I ask what country you are in, and what religion and/or spiritual tradition, or philosophical tradition, are you arguing from?
Re:Diseases of Affluence by randallsquared on Friday December 24, 2010 @07:37PM (#2038311)
I'm in the US, was raised as a Christian, and I'm talking about the mainstream view as reflected in the reaction of people whenever the possibility of preventing aging comes up. If you ask, "Do you think death is a good thing?", most people will say, "Of course not!", but when you ask about the possibility of extending life well into the second century, or living for millennia, suddenly objections are all you hear. In fiction, people who live for a very long time are mostly portrayed as being depressed about it -- "I wish I could die" is a common theme in vampire fiction, for example. People seem to want to live another year, but to think that living for another hundred years would be an awful fate.

There's a whole industry of people who try to convince people not to attempt to extend their life another year or another six months, but instead just die "with dignity", as though it's not dignified to live longer.

It's startling to me that you haven't seen at least the edges of this if you've been paying attention to "bioethics" (a too-self-congratulatory name, in my opinion) and similar debates.

Re:Diseases of Affluence by Mz on Friday December 24, 2010 @09:46AM (#2037317)
I get far worse treatment for such views elsewhere, so I'm not terribly concerned. I was basically posting in the middle of the night, unable to sleep. I felt it was a bad time to try to make such comments. Short version (fwiw): I think a lot of this has to do with body chemistry and (unrecognized) infection rather than calories per se.

I'm probably the stereotypical "woman driver" and was happy to let my husband drive when I was married. I currently live without a car and am happy to not have to deal with the issue of driving. Though, honestly, I have difficulty imagining how this particular navigation technique could contribute to such prejudices concerning women. Still, it was interesting that men were (apparently) literally better equipped for this than women.

Re:Diseases of Affluence by lkrubner on Friday December 24, 2010 @03:37PM (#2037961)
That sentence is interesting:

"They are certainly the longest-lived mammals on the planet. Indeed, they may be the longest-lived complex animals of any sort."

I wish I had the money to follow up on that. Of the long-lived vertebrate species (I mean the ones that can live in excess of 200 years) most seem to be at least occasionally exposed to high pressures in the deep sea (off hand, the only exception I can think of is land-based turtles, who also live a long time yet, as far as I know, never face deep sea pressures).

At this point there is a substantial literature suggesting health benefits, to humans, from hyperbaric oxygen therapy. Certainly, HBO seems to be an effective treatment for insulin resistance. This raises the question, is it the pressure, or the oxygen, or both, that creates the health benefit?

I can imagine arguments in both directions. Possibly the pure oxygen creates oxidative stress which then brings forth a response, as Wikipedia writes here (on a page about calorie restriction):

"Although aging can be conceptualized as the accumulation of damage, the more recent determination that free radicals participate in intracellular signaling has made the categorical equation of their effects with "damage" more problematic than was commonly appreciated in years past. It was previously proposed on a hypothetical basis that free radicals may induce an endogenous response culminating in more effective adaptations which protect against exogenous radicals (and possibly other toxic compounds).[49] Recent experimental evidence strongly suggests that this is indeed the case, and that such induction of endogenous free radical production extends life span of a model organism and mitohormetically exerts life extending and health promoting effects. Sublethal mitochondrial stress with an attendant stoichiometric augmentation of reactive oxygen species may precipitate many of the beneficial alterations in cellular physiology produced by caloric restriction."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calorie_restriction

But pressure can lead to the increase of a wide range of chemical reactions, and probably increases the activity of various enzymes. This is the angle that I think has not seen much research, and which I wish I had money to dive into myself. For instance, does resveratrol become more efficient when under pressure? Or when in a pure oxygen environment?

Re:Diseases of Affluence by Mz on Friday December 24, 2010 @03:48PM (#2037978)
Thank you. I read the article in large part because of my medical condition, which typically leads to lung damage and also puts one at high risk for a form of diabetes (as I understand it, neither "type 1" nor "type 2" -- something unique to the condition I have). I have done a lot to get healthier and I now live without a car and do a lot of walking as it is my main mode or transportation. I have read that inflammation may be at the root of diabetes. Inflammation is a major issue with my condition and there is much drug research which indicates you can reduce incidence of infection in people like me by controlling inflammation. I chose to control inflammation by making dietary and lifestyle changes rather than pursuing drugs as a primary defense.

I think the reduced lung function (over time) that my condition leads to, and thus reduced oxygenation is also a major factor in infection, even though I haven't really seen anything which states that per se. So I no longer believe that the primary benefit of exercise is "burning calories". I believe the primary benefit is oxygenation and other chemical changes it causes, which reduces infection and generally improves the body chemistry. I also think I survived my health crisis in part from having lived 3000 feet above sea level at one time, thereby forcibly expanding my lung capacity (I used to have a really narrow rib cage for someone my height and I look more normal since living 3000 feet above sea level).

Anyway, no real point here. Just rambling. But thank you for your thoughts.