I'm approaching it from the business perspective. If sipport staff are getting calls for poor performance then the product isn't working. End of story. Business units don't care about shades of gray and degraded service. It's binary for them. It's either working or it isn't. Couple that with financial penalties for latency and degraded service means even less. Either you're meeting your SLA or you aren't.
Degrading service, or more accurately, serving the maximum number of clients you can serve and no more is absolutely not the same thing as being down.
Failing/crashing rather than limiting the number of clients you serve is absolutely not established best practice. It's poor practice, in fact.