News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Replacing a silently failing disk in a ZFS pool by derefr on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @10:51AM (#20344736)
> It’s not like the FS would know the first time a disk re-reads a sector

I can understand why the default mode of operation for disks involves the disk presenting a clean “you get a block or you don’t” interface to the OS over e.g. SATA; but I’m surprised that it’s what we’re stuck with 100% of the time. We have ECC memory (where the memory controller reports errors to the OS), but no ECC disks.

Maybe this is what Apple is trying to do with putting their T2 chip in charge of being a storage controller. That way, it doesn’t just get to do encryption things; it can also make highly abstract policy-level decisions on what to do about these sorts of error events. Too bad such an approach is only really tenable if you’re building your own storage system out of your own raw NAND; it’d be nice to be able to have an external low-level storage controller built into e.g. the RAID card of a RAID array of regular HDDs, that those HDDs would then slave themselves to, and which ran OS-uploadable firmware.

There are no comments on this comment yet.