News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by stakhanov on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @07:37AM (#20343355)
Another male friend of mine, working for a U.S.-based tech startup, told me the following story: They are hiring a backend engineer right now. What applicants don't know: They want to hire a woman. Word came down from on high, that a team of 10 backend engineers being all-male is a situation that's going to end.

So they're hiring a woman, doing whatever it takes, as in: (a) making a conscious effort to lower the bar (b) making up a role that they don't even need with a job description that will appeal to women (c) paying high premiums for recruiting channels that will deliver female applicants (d) running the process in such a way that, unbeknownst to applicants due to legal ramifications, all applications by men are dead on arrival.

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by batbomb on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @08:13AM (#20343576)
they could always admit their ratios are way off, fire everybody, and create 10 new backend job applications - 5 of which will go to men and 5 to women, so that way their hiring is more fair to both men and women.

... Or the could do it the way they are doing it.

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by bin0 on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @09:24AM (#20344055)
The way you're phrasing it, they need to "admit guilt". They are guilty of nothing. First of all, what kind of heartless jerk fires every one to win PC points? That's a really bad practice, not fair to your employees, and I certainly wouldn't want to work for a company who did that.

Clearly, there are problems finding women. There are fewer women; that means it is not possible to have 50/50 across the board. He just said that they are lowering the bar. What are they doing about hiring that is unfair? Probably nothing, if they have to hire less-qualified women or a more-qualified man.

There are fewer women in tech. Why is immaterial to the current discussion. For better or for worse, that's where we are. If you want my two cents, I think part of it is risk. I worked in a start-up for a few years (not in the valley), and there was one female developer in a company of thirty. Why? I think men (especially young ones) are more willing to pick up and move for a high risk/high reward opportunity.

But all that aside, seriously, who actually advocates firing every one so you can have a nice press release? Would you want to lose your job to give some random woman one?

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by batbomb on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @10:30AM (#20344573)
> not fair to your employees

Certainly it's not fair to the employees. Certainly they probably didn't expect to get 10 men and 0 women in their current makeup. There may be no intentional guilt, but it's also not possible to know how they ended up with the makeup they have, 10 to 0, though it was probably incremental and without reflection on the makeup of the team along the way. Assuredly it probably wasn't malicious, but it's also like the people doing the hiring didn't reflect along the way - "hey, we've got 9 engineers and we need 10 and we are going to hire _another_ man for this role".

It's clear they (in this case the company) want to fix this in some way, as instructions "from on high" came down. Again company may or may not know how they got there. The company may also be failing to attract clients who want to vote with their dollars for a diverse company - so there could be a valid business case for this. Or not, maybe they just don't want a company with all dudes.

The original post was pointing out an unfair hiring practice due to this policy. I'm pointing out there is an alternative equitable hiring practice which actually leads to a fairer hiring practice for men and doesn't necessarily involve affirmative action, but that involves starting from scratch again (nobody said you'd necessarily lose your job - they could also easily make those positions available). Obviously this is not a tenable thought experiment, especially in academia thanks to tenure, so that's why we have these systems which, on the surface, may appear to discriminate against men. That said, many people interview for their current jobs in corporate restructurings all the time. That's probably not fair either, but it's accepted practice in the US.

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by bin0 on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @11:39AM (#20345246)
I don't understand what you mean. Do you really think they should hire a less-qualified person because of her sex? "we are going to hire _another_ man" - if he's the most qualified, why wouldn't you?

What is this equitable hiring practice? Fire your team over and over until you get more women? What if your ten most qualified applicants are again men? It seems very possible.

And what is this unfair hiring practice? How do you know the most qualified weren't all male? You are using the term "equitable" over "equal", and I'm assuming you understand the difference. I don't believe a company ought to disadvantage men to the advantage of women, because I don't believe discrimination is just.

As for your "nobody said you'd lose your job", yes, you did. Your assumption is that at least one man will lose his job for a woman.

You did not answer my question - would you, personally, be willing to quit your job to allow a woman to take it? Even were she less qualified?

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by MichaelGlass on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @07:45AM (#20343387)
Especially in Europe, it's very clear that in tech, there's a huge unfair bias for women. I mean look at the speaker lineups of conferences and management / tech teams of large tech organizations. It's hard to spot a single man among the ranks.

https://corporate.zalando.com/sites/default/files/media-down...

https://www.curry-on.org/2019/

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by doersino on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @08:02AM (#20343501)
I'm assuming you're being sarcastic, but for anyone who didn't check out the links:

Zalando:

> On top of this improved focus, we remain committed to increasing female leadership – our target is to have 25% of positions at the first level and 30% at the second level below the Management Board filled by women by 2022 (currently 11% and 16% respectively).

Curry On:

2/4 keynote speakers are men, 11/12 invited speakers are men, 29/32 presentations are held by men (as far as I can tell based on names and pictures).

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by the-dude on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @09:29AM (#20344086)
I assume it is a typo. The comment is inconsistent.
Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by krageon on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @08:35AM (#20343723)
I've been working in the EU for some time, and I have A. Not seen evidence of these policies B. Continued to note an overwhelming majority of my colleagues (90+%) is male.

When I go to conferences and look at management/tech teams, I see the opposite of what you are talking about: Very few women (or no women). I would like to know some of these woman-friendly conferences that you go to so I can actually attend, it might be nice.

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by roenxi on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @09:50AM (#20344233)
I assume the sociologists do actually ask a lot more questions and they simply don't filter through to tech boards, but the really interesting ones seem to me to be:

* Are average women making a more rational decisions than average men in avoiding these fields?

* Is there a difference in how much pain average men and women will tolerate before they leave? Ie, is the average man desperate to achieve a certain type of success, leading to increased competitiveness?

I think we all know that leadership positions in STEM companies and academia (and beyond) tend to skew male, the entry level incentives skew female and that females are the target of lots of unwanted male attention.

This obviously implies a bias, because half the apt are going to be female. However the efforts to correct this bias don't seem to have done their due diligence to figure out what the cause is; because at the moment the entry level incentives are clearly unfair in and of themselves. Two wrongs don't make Right, they make Very Wrong - it is a bad idea to correct bias by introducing more biases. Also, my experience in the mining industry makes me think that these incentives aren't likely to work because the cause of the bias is not concern about monetary compensation. I'll spare the crowd my personal theories.

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by shawnz on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @10:25AM (#20344533)
> However the efforts to correct this bias don't seem to have done their due diligence to figure out what the cause is; because at the moment the entry level incentives are clearly unfair in and of themselves. Two wrongs don't make Right, they make Very Wrong - it is a bad idea to correct bias by introducing more biases.

What if the cause is due to the existing precedent? Then wouldn't positive discrimination be an effective solution?

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by the-dude on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @08:13AM (#20343577)
Is there a bias, or might they not be interested in the fields?
Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by skocznymroczny on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @08:29AM (#20343668)
Even if they're not interested in the fields, they're definitely interested in well-paid jobs in air-conditioned offices.
Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by the-dude on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @08:37AM (#20343737)
Are you sure? The impression I get in NL is that women don't particular like to work too much : they favor 32 over 40 hrs. I even overheard a young woman say she went to 24 hrs ( from 32 hrs ), because 'why not?', they could afford it.

My impression is women are less ambitious and value quality of life much more than men ( I don't blame them, I try to do as little as possible as well ).

Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by silveroriole on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @09:59AM (#20344306)
My perception is that if a man works less than full time, people think he must be a go-getter who isn’t afraid to ask his boss for it, must be earning a lot already, etc. It’s seen as an enviable position to be in. When women work less than full time they tend to be called “unambitious”.
Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by redleader9345 on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @08:59AM (#20343894)
Can't one be ambitious about not getting overworked?
Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by losvedir on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @09:53AM (#20344255)
Sure, if one can be lazy about doing recreational activities.
Re:Max Planck Society conducts bullying survey by mises on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @09:30AM (#20344093)
Since when is 40hrs/wk overworked? I work significantly more than that and don't consider myself overworked.