News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Origin of Banking (2016) by Spooky23 on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @12:39AM (#20341623)
Makes sense. Academics always discount the intelligence of past people.

People seem to naturally pledge loyalty and do favors for each other, it makes sense that “debt” would be a primary medium of exchange.

If anything, barter is more complex than a promise, as without money how do you evaluate the value of a sheep vs a bunch of grain or some service? Is building a wall worth more or less than sex? How do the two match up against the sheep? How do you trade for fractional value?

The big difference innovation was the organized trading of debt and shares of enterprises a couple hundred years ago. The rest is probably been a thing since cavemen.

Re:The Origin of Banking (2016) by chrstphrhrt on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @01:00AM (#20341718)
"Academics always discount the intelligence of past people."

...except maybe in the discipline of history, some of whom love to overestimate the greatness of past individuals.

It also sounds like you are worshiping some kind of idol of the token of exchange. One main function of law is to allow for promises far more complex than any simple transaction.

Re:The Origin of Banking (2016) by erikpukinskis on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @01:51PM (#20346719)
> you are worshiping some kind of idol of the token of exchange

Sure. If defining a word by what it is and then applying that definition to past people is “worshiping” an “idol”. I would call it “adhering to” a “definition”.

Fact: History, as a written corpus, pins the “invention” of a lot of things on white people, when Arabs, Chinese, or Mezoerican people “invented” those “fundamental economic tools” thousands of years before. Stock and debt being good examples.

Re:The Origin of Banking (2016) by erikpukinskis on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @12:05PM (#20345548)
Trading shares was invented a couple hundred years ago?