> Second, I want to talk about why this particular issue is so important. Not why privacy is important; we are all already learning that the hard way. Rather, why making ethical decisions at the earliest stages of your company is important.
> When a company first forms, there are no norms or principles guiding how its people should make decisions. It’s basically just what’s in the founders’ heads. With each decision a company makes, its “decision genome” is established and subsequently hardened...
In other words, if this is a decision Superhuman made early on and embedded into its main product, then, the author argues, we should be very wary of its culture, and how it will weigh-in on privacy issues going forward. It's from this claim that the author seems to have built his anger on.
Read receipts have been a feature of email and messaging clients for at least more than a decade now. Among the tech-literate, the tradeoffs and potential problems/controversies are well-known, such that opting-in (or out) of read receipts is a near-ubiquitous option in every service's account settings. I'm sorry, but it really stretches plausibility to think that Superhuman put in as little thought about it as you propose.
[0] https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/superhuman#section-o...
What about non technical people who have no way of learning that they are being spied upon?
I may be wrong.
"Do you care if your ex-girl/boyfriend can tell every time you read an old email s/he sent you?"
"Have you disabled loading images by default in your email client?"
You will see that you are wrong.
EDIT: decided to listen to my own advice and conduct a (very non scientific obvs) twitter poll.
Setting aside the difficulty, being pressured to disable a generic feature (image loading) for a degenerate use case of that feature (user tracking) is annoying.
Other email clients support 'read receipts' without using tracking pixels. It's not impossible that Superhuman chose to use tracking pixels for a good reason, but I can't think of one and I haven't read of one either.
The conversation could have easily been
"Read receipts are a useful feature." "Yeah. Let's add them"
And that was it. Lots of people are not privacy focused and don't think of this as a problem, so it would never occur that their seemingly benign feature could have bigger consequences.
It's pretty easy for people who care to "turn off read receipts" by disabling images or blocking it through proxy/vpn/whatever.
I personally don't like read receipts, so I will likely not use superhuman. I just don't view it as some major problem.