Re:More Mistakes Discovered In DHS's Domain Seizures
by regularfry on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @03:48PM
(#2032389)
How about "The ICE is tasked with policing counterfeiting so this isn't overstepping the bounds of their jurisdiction?" Quibbling over the words "power grab" seems rather pointless.
Re:More Mistakes Discovered In DHS's Domain Seizures
by joe_the_user on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @05:44PM
(#2032748)
The summary of an article can matter a lot these days. If someone says "TL;DR - not a power grab", it may make someone who would otherwise react against it do nothing.
This is a significant increase in state power. I hardly oppose any summary which gives any other impression.
Re:More Mistakes Discovered In DHS's Domain Seizures
by puredemo on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @07:44PM
(#2033105)
You meant heartily.
Re:More Mistakes Discovered In DHS's Domain Seizures
by joe_the_user on Thursday December 23, 2010 @02:49AM
(#2033845)
Yes I did ;<
I keep hearing the ICE-is-tasked-with-counterfeiting-so-this-isn't-a-power-grab argument.
Whatever the merits of the general argument, you need to find a different term for you say it isn't. Because it certainly is a power grab by the normal use of the phrase.
We haven't seen mass domain seizures previously and this ability certainly is power. It's been done with dubious legality, dubious constitutionality and just dubiously, so it's effectively a grab.
If the Department of Agriculture started arresting people for using too many pesticides in their home gardens, it would be a power-grab even though the department sure-enough is tasked with regulating agriculture.