They could just randomly skip some numbers. That would maintain the XXX to YYY advantage.
Does that resolve the problem, or just add another variable to the analysis?
Re:The German Tank Problem
by mattkrause on Sunday June 30, 2019 @07:14PM
(#20321194)
Naively, it would inflate the absolute values, but you might be able to correct for it in various ways. Still, knowing that tank production fell 50% is probably useful, even if you don't know what exactly it fell from....
Still, the idea that this could leak valuable information is probably more obvious in hindsight, and sequential serial numbers do have some upsides. If there's a design flaw in one version of the gearboxes, you can just pull everything with a serial number between XXXX and YYYY. With randomized numbers, you'd have to maintain some master database, which is a lot harder when most of logging is done with pen-and-ink ledgers, carbon copies, and maybe punchcards.