News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: chat going up or down? by gojomo on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @11:51AM (#2031688)
Join the future, not the past: put the newest statements on top.

True, most other live-chats do the reverse. But Twitter, blogs, and feeds are training people to read upward – it's the layout with momentum.

The old way was dictated by handwriting and then typewriters; it's no longer required with most written communication keyed-in. Even where a physical reason may exist to prefer a text entry box near the keyboard, as on smartphones, it's still easy enough to compose-at-top (as evidenced by URL bars and search boxes). Or, a covering animation could cause messages to visually 'whoosh' from bottom-entry-area to latest-on-top upon send.

I expect at some point a tipping point will be reached – perhaps as a generational thing, or when some other post-Twitter channel takes off – after which even older interfaces will flip. (Is there an IRC client that's latest-on-top yet? If not, I expect one soon.)

Eventually, even prose that seeks to create a strong sense of time-falling-in-from-the-top may reverse its usual line-ordering.

There are no comments on this comment yet.