Re:Where Is Awarded "The Mother of All Geofencing Patents"
by ergo98 on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @12:09PM
(#2031737)
Agreed. This patent is not the mother of all geofencing patents: They seemed to have made it specific enough that it is actually not the egregious sort of patent abuse that we so commonly see.
A patent can have multiple independent claims, independently enforceable. In this case, however, there are only a few independent claims, each a simple rewrite that only marginally changes scope. The reset are dependent claims that are specializations.
All of the claims here seem to depend on the portable device having a graphical map of the "geofence". The patent isn't relevant at all on a system that doesn't have this property.
So it seems that the patent is pretty limited to me. Any location based system that does not graphically show a boundary on the portable device itself will not fall foul of this patent (as far as I can see).