Re:Nobel Prize Winner William Nordhaus vs. the IPCC on Clima...
by AlexandrB on Friday June 28, 2019 @11:45AM
(#20305518)
I don't think pointing out the biased nature of the source is an ad-hominem. It's pretty standard critical analysis.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Nobel Prize Winner William Nordhaus vs. the IPCC on Clima...
by readams on Friday June 28, 2019 @11:47AM
(#20305541)
That's literally what ad hominem means...
Re:Nobel Prize Winner William Nordhaus vs. the IPCC on Clima...
by pwinnski on Friday June 28, 2019 @12:08PM
(#20305790)
This is false.
Ad hominem refers to dismissing an argument out of hand based on the source. In this case, people are willing to engage with the argument, but are additionally pointing out the bias inherent in the source. This is not ad hominem, just a bias warning.
Re:Nobel Prize Winner William Nordhaus vs. the IPCC on Clima...
by ameister14 on Friday June 28, 2019 @12:27PM
(#20306022)
I don't think ad hominem is necessarily dismissing an argument out of hand - it's ignoring the content of an argument in favor of countering the speaker.
Ad hominem isn't always irrelevant, but questioning a source's motivation instead of responding to the arguments they make seems to be ad hominem.