One could even argue that AT&T violated their end of the contract by throttling NetFlix (they no longer provide you with the same service they did the month before) and you should be able to get out ETF free (IANAL)
I hope to find this stands up in court.
If this is in the carriers plans, I would be certain that their lawyers make sure the definition of service is sufficiently vague.
Courts don't rule on just what is written, but also on what should be writable. You can't contract away many things.
For the record, I watch Netflix over AT&T 3G all the time, and it works very well for me.
Re:FCC Adopts Net Neutrality Lite
by thebooktocome on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @03:41PM
(#2029286)
It was a hypothetical situation. "If [AT&T] suddenly starts throttling..."
I guess I misunderstood the part that said "(let's imagine for a moment that Netflix is watchable over 3G)"...
Re:FCC Adopts Net Neutrality Lite
by mortenjorck on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @10:40AM
(#2031530)
You understood correctly -- has Netflix since added a lower bitrate for 3G? The last time I tried to stream over AT&T it would buffer about five seconds for every one second of video.
I've only really started using it recently, and I can watch an entire Doctor Who episode at full quality with only 4 bars of service (iPhone 4). At weaker signals the quality drops before it buffers (I'd honestly rather it buffered).
Of course, I'm not in SF or NYC or anywhere else with notorious bad AT&T service.
If my AT&T DSL suddenly starts throttling Netflix, I don't have a whole lot of options apart from moving. If my AT&T 3G starts throttling Netflix (let's imagine for a moment that Netflix is watchable over 3G), I have a few options: I can wait until my contract is over and switch then, I can pay an ETF and switch now, and chances are, there are two or three other viable competitors in my market once I'm off contract. And none of these can just silently start throttling either, per the transparency requirement.
Of course, the dangers are still there: The market could decide together to start throttling and dealing, some more carrier mergers could sweet-talk their way past the SEC, and a highly un-neutral net could become yet another stifling fact of life in the US wireless market.