Like it or not, many people who self-describe as feminists are actually seeking a privileged position for women. Many people who self-describe as seeking "social justice" are actually far left wing extremists pushing fairly radical proposals. Extremists in these groups tend to use minor offenses as a club to tar their political opponents [1], and the rest of the world is treating the entire group as the boy who cried wolf.
It's hardly an issue restricted to feminists or social justice types. The Tea Party faces similar issues - they didn't immediately kick the racists out when they started and now the entire movement is viewed as racist.
[1] I don't think the author of this blog post is necessarily one of them. She is just a young kid who took the rhetoric of her tribe too seriously.
By the way, why the double post?
This is a media distortion.
"Many people who self-describe as seeking "social justice" are actually far left wing extremists pushing fairly radical proposals."
I could see how that might seem to be the case in a country that's been driven as far to the right as the US has. Where Jimmy Carter, Clinton, and Obama are also branded "far-left radicals" and "socialist Nazis".
Wanting people to be treated fairly is now seen as an "extremist", "radical" position.
"By the way, why the double post?"
Because the first post was just a reply to the first person who got distracted by the gender pronoun point to the exclusion of the more important point I addressed in my post. Then a whole bunch of other people effectively started saying the same thing. So I decided to post a general reply instead. I would have deleted the original reply, but it already had a reply, so I kept it.
Are you seriously asserting extremist feminists seeking privileges for women don't exist? I've met them. In the interests of being verifiable, I'll link to a particularly noxious example:
"At a stroke, the one thing that women had going for them [the ability to commit paternity fraud] has been taken away, the one respect in which they had the last laugh over their husbands and lovers. DNA tests are an anti-feminist appliance of science…"
http://www.spectator.co.uk/essays/all/6391918/whos-the-daddy...
All organizations, movements and political affiliations have crazies, and very often they will come to dominate the media attention. It's just a sad fact of life. And no, your favorite organizations are not immune.
And no, I won't be drawn into a discussion of the merits of "social justice" (whatever that means). It's utterly irrelevant to the point I was making. As I said, my point applies equally well to the Tea Party, a rather disorganized group who's aims I'm moderately sympathetic to.
Of course they exist. But I wouldn't call them "many", as you did in your original reply. They're a minority. The vast majority of feminists are simply after being treated no worse than men. A "radical" and "far-left" idea, I know.
And since when did some Spectator columnist become the spokesperson for feminism?
My main point is that there are sufficiently many for the outside world to perceive the entire movement as mostly crazy. And no matter how much you try to make this a political thing, it isn't. Right wing groups (like the tea party, libertarians, etc) face similar problems.
Well, I'm not sure how representative one person's experience with "feminists" is. Personally, I've never met any "feminists" of the kind you describe.
But, instead of taking two such datapoints as representative, why don't we look at what the NOW, the National Organization for Women, "the largest feminist organization in the United States" (with 500,000 contributing members and 5,987 chapters in 47 U.S. states) has as its stated purpose:
To take action to bring women into full participation
in the mainstream of American society now, exercising
all privileges and responsibilities thereof in truly
equal partnership with men.
Does this sound so "crazy" or "extreme"? This is what feminism is about. What you've encountered is a minority deviation and what you've heard about feminism is a distortion. Feminists are not after dominance. They're after fairness and equal treatment."My main point is that there are sufficiently many for the outside world to perceive the entire movement as mostly crazy."
I don't think this is a consequence of people meeting lots of "crazy feminists". I don't think most people meet any feminists of any sort whatsoever. Their views are largely shaped by the media. Which, in the US, is largely controlled by the right wing, who are rabidly anti-feminist.
Also, the media tends to jump on any sensationalist story. So it's not really surprising that it's the extremists who'd get much of the spotlight. But they are not representative, by any means.
NOW is the girl crying wolf. "Oh noes, a vampire show depicting sex and violence against a woman!" (It's the media's latest "Outrage") http://www.now.org/issues/media/hall-of-shame/index.php
If you want people to do something other than dismiss you as one of those "social justice people", you need to disassociate yourself from NOW and their ilk.
Also, NOW explicitly opposes equality when it gets in the way of special privileges for women/minorities. See section 5 of their proposed "Constitutional Equality Amendment".
You also completely ignore the host of major issues that NOW has taken important stands on in its 40 year history and focus on these two things, as if that's all NOW was about.
I think this will be my last post in this thread. I didn't mean to get in to an hours-long debate about this.
From an international perspective, I cannot take feminism in the US seriously, I just can't. In the original post, for example, the author takes issue with the WORDING OF A TEXT BOOK. Are you f__ing kidding me? Is that a problem, noteworthy for feminists to tackle? No. Again, going back to the international context: do people know, how women are treated not only in the Middle East, but in the Balkans, Eastern Europe, Russia and CIS or Turkey? _THAT_ is discrimination. _THAT_ is what feminism should be fighting against. _NOT_ about some silly issues in grammar and style.
The larger and more important issue is the utter contempt for feminism (which, at its best simply strives to have women be treated no worse than men), and the contempt for "social justice people" (ie. people who actually care about justice for everyone) that the poster's friend demonstrated.
And this contempt came from someone who feminists and "social justice people" were concerned with helping. Instead of any kind of constructive or even thoughtful comment on the issue, the author's friend simply contemptuously dismissed her and everyone who cares about any of these issues.
That's the larger problem. Contemptuous dismissal of people who are actually interested and motivated to help move society forward.