Re:The West’s failed fight against China’s ‘Cloud Hopper’ ha...
by mistermann on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @12:34PM
(#20286584)
Ah I see, this makes sense.
In my experience, it's almost always used in the latter (incorrect) sense.
Re:The West’s failed fight against China’s ‘Cloud Hopper’ ha...
by sbov on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @04:35PM
(#20288866)
In a logical discussion whataboutism is never a relevant response. If something is bad it is bad if any side does it. But hypocrisy as a fallacy don't necessarily apply when discussing geopolitical power struggles. This is because people on one side using a tactic but not the other is usually a disadvantage, so when someone accuses you of hypocrisy they're basically saying that you're trying to get me to stop, but you won't, which will give you the upper hand, so... why should I stop?
When you bring up something quite related to the presented problem, that's not whataboutism.