Re:A Teenager's IoT worm is bricking thousands of devices
by rndgermandude on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @11:57AM
(#20286206)
Speaking EU/Germany-centric, the problem with suing a company is that the company can always make the case go away by replacing the faulty product with either a repaired product, a very similar product of equal or greater worth or refunding a customer for the product and any losses incurred. A court will readily accept this even if the plaintiff customer might not want to accept it. And it's better to just silence a single suit this way (or a few) than to get a sentence against you on the books that will encourage everybody else to demand replacements or even sue too.
Re:A Teenager's IoT worm is bricking thousands of devices
by ahje on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @02:53PM
(#20287996)
Exactly. I've returned products due to firmware problems in the past, although they were not security related. In one case I was asked to give a written description of the problem before I got a refund. The other store returned the money without questions. It's not really any different from a product that broke under warranty in my experience.
It would be just the question of somebody testing it. Take a relatively new() device with unpatched security hole, try to get it replaced/refunded and if necessary proceed to court to get a decision on the matter.
Although I wonder if any vendor actually wants to go to court arguing that a product with severe security issue is actually working as intended.
() Safe bet should be a device purchased less than 2 years ago, since that seems to be the time the vendor is at least responsible for defects.