Re:A Teenager's IoT worm is bricking thousands of devices
by TeMPOraL on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @05:53AM
(#20283400)
> you think people would support your cause of measuring everything in dollars and going around destroying their property because they're "just as dangerous as food poisoning"?
"People", in general, are dumb. Individuals, when explained, might actually support it, but I guess you'd have to start teaching the following in school:
If you want to compare things, you need to express them with the same unit. It so happens that there is universal unit already in use to compare everything to everything else - money. Which, internationally, means dollars. Moral caveats apply, but this is how you correctly compare arbitrary things when you lack a more suitable common unit.
> Like, seriously? If you went around and asked people whether their restaurants should be shut down for unsanitary practices, do you think you would get a response on the same planet as what you would get if you asked them about their IoT devices getting shut down? Come on.
Sure, why not.
Unsanitary practices: you weigh some people likely ending up in the hospital with food poisoning against shutting down a business employing a dozen or more people for unspecified amount of time, which may or may not have pretty bad secondary effects (e.g. waiters aren't exactly the kind of people who can afford asudden job loss).
IoT botnet: you weigh bricking a bunch of (at this point in time) non-essential trinkets, thus inconveniencing innocent consumers and making it worse for garbage companies who shouldn't be in business in the first place, vs. enabling moderate-probability inconveniencing events for thousands to millions of people, such as DDoSing random websites, and occasional low-probability high-impact event, such as Maersk getting pwnd and disrupting worldwide shipping.
Ultimately I'd expect the IoT scenario to be less important than food poisoning scenario when you tally up both sides of both choices - and accordingly, food poisoning is something governments worldwide are already dealing with. However, and circling back to tty2300's original comment, the pattern of thinking is pretty much the same here in both scenarios.
"People", in general, are dumb. Individuals, when explained, might actually support it, but I guess you'd have to start teaching the following in school:
If you want to compare things, you need to express them with the same unit. It so happens that there is universal unit already in use to compare everything to everything else - money. Which, internationally, means dollars. Moral caveats apply, but this is how you correctly compare arbitrary things when you lack a more suitable common unit.
> Like, seriously? If you went around and asked people whether their restaurants should be shut down for unsanitary practices, do you think you would get a response on the same planet as what you would get if you asked them about their IoT devices getting shut down? Come on.
Sure, why not.
Unsanitary practices: you weigh some people likely ending up in the hospital with food poisoning against shutting down a business employing a dozen or more people for unspecified amount of time, which may or may not have pretty bad secondary effects (e.g. waiters aren't exactly the kind of people who can afford asudden job loss).
IoT botnet: you weigh bricking a bunch of (at this point in time) non-essential trinkets, thus inconveniencing innocent consumers and making it worse for garbage companies who shouldn't be in business in the first place, vs. enabling moderate-probability inconveniencing events for thousands to millions of people, such as DDoSing random websites, and occasional low-probability high-impact event, such as Maersk getting pwnd and disrupting worldwide shipping.
Ultimately I'd expect the IoT scenario to be less important than food poisoning scenario when you tally up both sides of both choices - and accordingly, food poisoning is something governments worldwide are already dealing with. However, and circling back to tty2300's original comment, the pattern of thinking is pretty much the same here in both scenarios.