News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI Models Predict Breast Cancer with Radiologist-Level Ac... by rscho on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @04:37AM (#20282997)
The job of a radiologist is to construct a story that holds water around the diagnosis and communicate that to other specialists, so they can use that to understand the problem at hand.

Concretely, a radiologist may say "there is a lesion compatible with your presumption of diagnosis X, however another neighbouring lesion Y speaks against diagnosis X. In light of patient history, further examination of lesion Y by modality Z is advised". That's the minimum we expect, otherwise we wouldn't need radiologists because many specialists can analyze the images relevant to their specialty themselves.

I don't deny it will be possible to automate in the future, but currently not possible. Radiologists are useful, and their job lies beyond matters of image description.

Re:AI Models Predict Breast Cancer with Radiologist-Level Ac... by WhitneyLand on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @02:34PM (#20287826)
Sounds like we're in perfect agreement on the critical points and the only debate would be around the timeframe (10 years or ?).

- It will be possible to automate a large % of a radiologists job in the future, it's currently not possible.

- Radiologists are useful and their job lies beyond matters of image description