News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI Models Predict Breast Cancer with Radiologist-Level Ac... by taneq on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @12:09AM (#20281823)
> The problem is that they fail differently than humans do, in a way that humans wind up not trusting the results.

Not only that, but human fallibility is accepted where machine fallibility is not. There's something about being a "person" which makes it acceptable for you to just take the blame for something. A senior radiologist makes a glaring error and "it happens, people make mistakes". A computer makes the same error and it's a problem which must be fixed before the computer can be trusted.

Ultimately I believe this is a cognitive bias that we're just going to have to learn to let go of.

Re:AI Models Predict Breast Cancer with Radiologist-Level Ac... by semi-extrinsic on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @02:09AM (#20282314)
> Ultimately I believe this is a cognitive bias that we're just going to have to learn to let go of.

Unfortunately I don't think this is merely cognitive bias. It's actually built into our legal system at a pretty fundamental level: machines are held to a higher standard than humans when it comes to failures with grave consequences.

And keep in mind, this system only achieves the same accuracy as doctors. What is the wnd benefit, other than shifting where money flows?

Do you really think this benefit is substantial enough that we will se major overhauls of tort law in all US states and in every country in the rest of the world?

Re:AI Models Predict Breast Cancer with Radiologist-Level Ac... by psychoslave on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @02:38AM (#20282433)
> Unfortunately I don't think this is merely cognitive bias. It's actually built into our legal system at a pretty fundamental level: machines are held to a higher standard than humans when it comes to failures with grave consequences.

Well, laws reflect culturo-cognitive biases, don't they? And also they evolve.

For the last part, that seems to generally be a wise "bias": when a machine fails, chances are good that all the identical machines will fail the same way.

When a human err, chances are good that this won't be in a way you might expect to identically happen in all its peers, although common cultural biases can happen obviously.

Also so far, our machine are far less expected to self-correct their behaviors when they err, especially regarding some untold social exceptions that were not met through some unexpected side effects.

Ultimately, machines don't care of consequences of their acts because they don't have any feeling of responsibility to someone they love, not even themselves.