Re:I’m in the 1 Percent. Please, Raise My Taxes
by Gibbon1 on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @05:42PM
(#20279292)
> bad faith
Yeah that's my thought. 'Why don't you personally go do that and get back to us' in response to argument for collective action is a bad faith response.
Re:I’m in the 1 Percent. Please, Raise My Taxes
by komali2 on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @06:28PM
(#20279706)
>Why don't you personally go do that and get back to us
So, he did that. He works full time as a philanthropist, then came back to us with this blog post and said "I alone can't fix this, we need collective action, in the form of higher taxes on the rich."
The typical argument made by fiscal conservatives is "the philanthropists will remove the need of the welfare state." This rich philanthropist is writing this article to say "that is incorrect, it isn't enough."
Re:I’m in the 1 Percent. Please, Raise My Taxes
by slang800 on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @06:21PM
(#20279649)
> The problem is it'd vanish into a black hole
It doesn't just vanish, it reduces inflation which allows more money to be spent by congress. It would only be able to "vanish" if you were paying your taxes with a non-fiat currency.
In any case, to answer your question: No, the IRS doesn't prohibit it, and as far as I can tell it's not illegal.
https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/the-right-to-pay-no-more-than-t...
> Taxpayers who overpaid their taxes can file for a refund. Taxpayers must file a claim for a credit or refund by the later of these two dates: Three years from the date they filed their original return. Two years from the date they paid the tax.
I guess if you overpaid, didn't file for a refund, and waited 3 years, the money would just vanish.
The problem is it'd vanish into a black hole - no congressional committee has budgeted for that "extra" money to suddenly appear, there's not really any accountability for it like you'd have for charity.
A higher tax rate means that economists can much more confidently say "this is how much money the US government will have for spending in 2020" than guessing how much ultra-wealthy will pay, and then not request refund on.