News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sanders proposes canceling entire $1.6T in U.S. student l... by mruts on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @04:28AM (#20272149)
This kind of populist pandering makes me upset. What about people who didn’t go to college? Or people who killed themselves to pay off their student loans? This is nothing more than wealth transfer to a specific demographic (young, educated) to buy off voters. This isn’t how a democracy should function.
Re:Sanders proposes canceling entire $1.6T in U.S. student l... by notacoward on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @08:22AM (#20273463)
> What about people who didn’t go to college? Or people who killed themselves to pay off their student loans?

I think you're misunderstanding the goal here. It's not to create equal outcomes. It's to stop the ongoing harm to students and to society from these abusive practices. Personally I think it would be better if these debts were capped at some non-zero number instead of being erased entirely, with the difference directed toward some of the other groups you mention, but at least this starts the conversation. Negotiation 101: start with an offer that's more favorable to you than where you expect to end up.

> This isn’t how a democracy should function.

This is exactly how a democracy should function - with proposals, then discussion, then votes. What about the back-room deals that have inflated college costs and created special regulatory exemptions for student loans? Anyone who complains about "populist pandering" without at least acknowledging the anti-populist pandering that led to this is being a bit disingenuous.

Re:Sanders proposes canceling entire $1.6T in U.S. student l... by cyrksoft on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @05:28PM (#20279158)
> I think you're misunderstanding the goal here. It's not to create equal outcomes. It's to stop the ongoing harm to students and to society from these abusive practices. Personally I think it would be better if these debts were capped at some non-zero number instead of being erased entirely, with the difference directed toward some of the other groups you mention, but at least this starts the conversation. Negotiation 101: start with an offer that's more favorable to you than where you expect to end up.

Which abusive practices are you referring to?

Re:Sanders proposes canceling entire $1.6T in U.S. student l... by notacoward on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @06:29PM (#20279712)
Oh, where to begin? It's a complicated racket. Here are a couple of quick hits illustrating the way that the government has made special rules for student loans that make them unusually attractive to lenders.

http://www.collegescholarships.org/research/student-loans/ http://www.healthcareadministration.com/college/

For a longer treatment, covering the schools' role as well, it would be hard to beat Matt Taibbi's expose.

https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/the-...

My original comment was primarily directed at the lenders, but the other parties deserve their share of calumny as well.

Re:Sanders proposes canceling entire $1.6T in U.S. student l... by cyrksoft on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @08:41PM (#20280826)
The main problem here is people taking these loans. Why would anybody take out 150k to study something 'useless'? It's entirely their fault.

Of course the loans made education more expensive, nobody argues that. But the main focus should be on people taking the money for the sake of taking it and then realizing they screwed up.

Re:Sanders proposes canceling entire $1.6T in U.S. student l... by notacoward on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @11:17PM (#20281591)
> Why would anybody take out 150k to study something 'useless'?

Who are you to say it's useless? Such hubris. They do it because they've been led to believe it's necessary, and in some cases it actually is. Kind of hard to become a doctor or lawyer without a degree. Even if that weren't the case, that doesn't absolve the people who take advantage of them. Victims of fraud are acting voluntarily, but that doesn't make it OK to defraud someone else.

> people taking the money for the sake of taking it

You can't even know others' motives, and yet you choose to assume the worst possible ones. That says more about you than them.

Re:Sanders proposes canceling entire $1.6T in U.S. student l... by cyrksoft on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @09:08AM (#20284558)
> Who are you to say it's useless? Such hubris. They do it because they've been led to believe it's necessary, and in some cases it actually is. Kind of hard to become a doctor or lawyer without a degree. Even if that weren't the case, that doesn't absolve the people who take advantage of them. Victims of fraud are acting voluntarily, but that doesn't make it OK to defraud someone else.

That's why I wrote 'useless'. By that I mean degrees without real job prospects.

> You can't even know others' motives, and yet you choose to assume the worst possible ones. That says more about you than them.

I'm not judging anybody. I know people who took 30k loans without needing them just to pay for a new car, new computer and other non-necessities. They were studying art at a community college. There are many people like that. That's entirely their fault and their debt to pay.

Re:Sanders proposes canceling entire $1.6T in U.S. student l... by notacoward on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @12:38PM (#20286630)
> I know people who took 30k loans without needing them just to pay for a new car, new computer and other non-necessities.

It's interesting that you know multiple such people, but what matters is the statistical reality. Do such "frivolous" loan-takers represent anything even remotely approaching a majority of all who have loans, to justify a sweeping generalization or affect policy?

Re:Sanders proposes canceling entire $1.6T in U.S. student l... by cyrksoft on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @01:24PM (#20287072)
I never said everybody or a majority of people did that. I just wanted to point out that those cases existed.

83% of student loan debts are lower than 50k. I don't see a problem there. If you made a bad career decision or decided to go to a more expensive college it's your burden to carry.

Re:Sanders proposes canceling entire $1.6T in U.S. student l... by woah on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @10:48AM (#20274752)
It’s not “back room deals” that have made tuition prices balloon, it’s the government loans themselves.
Re:Sanders proposes canceling entire $1.6T in U.S. student l... by notacoward on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @11:00AM (#20274903)
It's both. The availability of both grants and loans has been a huge factor, to be sure, but so have the direct subsidies to schools, and the special rules that make such loans more appealing to lenders, and all the "little ways" that regulation drives up either demand or cost for a college education. But it doesn't even matter, really. Whether they were made in the front room or the back room, many of the deals contributing to the debt crisis were made to benefit a few at the expense of the public. Decrying one kind of pandering while denying another never leads to good policy.